Skip to main content

Co-cultures of Propionibacterium freudenreichii and Bacillus amyloliquefaciens cooperatively upgrade sunflower seed milk to high levels of vitamin B12 and multiple co-benefits



Sunflower seeds (Helianthus annuus) display an attractive source for the rapidly increasing market of plant-based human nutrition. Of particular interest are press cakes of the seeds, cheap residuals from sunflower oil manufacturing that offer attractive sustainability and economic benefits. Admittedly, sunflower seed milk, derived therefrom, suffers from limited nutritional value, undesired flavor, and the presence of indigestible sugars. Of specific relevance is the absence of vitamin B12. This vitamin is required for development and function of the central nervous system, healthy red blood cell formation, and DNA synthesis, and displays the most important micronutrient for vegans to be aware of. Here we evaluated the power of microbes to enrich sunflower seed milk nutritionally as well as in flavor.


Propionibacterium freudenreichii NCC 1177 showed highest vitamin B12 production in sunflower seed milk out of a range of food-grade propionibacteria. Its growth and B12 production capacity, however, were limited by a lack of accessible carbon sources and stimulants of B12 biosynthesis in the plant milk. This was overcome by co-cultivation with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, which supplied lactate, amino acids, and vitamin B7 for growth of NCC 1177 plus vitamins B2 and B3, potentially supporting vitamin B12 production by the Propionibacterium. After several rounds of optimization, co-fermentation of ultra-high-temperature pre-treated sunflower seed milk by the two microbes, enabled the production of 17 µg (100 g)−1 vitamin B12 within four days without any further supplementation. The fermented milk further revealed significantly enriched levels of l-lysine, the most limiting essential amino acid, vitamin B3, vitamin B6, improved protein quality and flavor, and largely eliminated indigestible sugars.


The fermented sunflower seed milk, obtained by using two food-grade microbes without further supplementation, displays an attractive, clean-label product with a high level of vitamin B12 and multiple co-benefits. The secret of the successfully upgraded plant milk lies in the multifunctional cooperation of the two microbes, which were combined, based on their genetic potential and metabolic signatures found in mono-culture fermentations. This design by knowledge approach appears valuable for future development of plant-based milk products.


The world market of plant-based milk alternatives is rapidly increasing [1] and, notably, expected to surpass US$ 26 billion by 2023 [2]. Among various legumes and nuts, sunflower seeds (Helianthus annuus) emerge as attractive source for plant-based milk alternatives, given their high ecological sustainability, a natural richness in protein, magnesium and potassium, and a relatively low abundance in anti-nutritional factors and toxins [1, 3,4,5]. In addition, they are nut-free and suit consumers with celiac disease and food allergies. Of particular interest as raw material are the (defatted) press cakes of sunflower seeds, cheap residuals from sunflower oil manufacturing that offer attractive eco-friendliness and economic benefits [6]. It is therefore no surprise that sunflower seed suspensions (termed sunflower seed milk in this study due to their milk-like appearance) have found broad application as milk, yogurt, smoothies, and butter, among other products [6,7,8]. Admittedly, sunflower seed milk does not match animal milk in all desired characteristics, a drawback that is commonly reported for plant-based milk alternatives and requires upgrading [9].

One of the most severe limitations of plant-based products in general, and specifically sunflower seed milk, is the lack of vitamin B12 (cobalamin). Chemically, vitamin B12 is a cobalt-containing tetrapyrrole, one of the most complex small molecules made by nature [10]. It is crucial for neurodevelopment, cell division and cell differentiation, and displays the most important micronutrient for vegans to be aware of Ref. [11, 12]. Notably, only a few bacteria can make vitamin B12 [13]. Cobalt is found at the center of the molecule and is therefore ultimately required for biosynthesis [14]. In addition, the lower-ligand B12 precursor dimethylbenzimidazole (DMBI), its starter unit riboflavin (vitamin B2), nicotinamide (vitamin B3), catalytically involved in DMBI formation, and oxygen availability have been shown to support vitamin B12 production [14, 15], underlining the complexity of the biosynthetic process.

Other undesired features of sunflower seed milk are low levels of essential amino acids, especially l-lysine [16], the presence of indigestible sugars such as stachyose and raffinose [17], and a bitter, seedy taste [18, 19]. To overcome B12 limitation in plant-based materials, direct supplementation of limiting ingredients is a common way [20, 21]. However, this adds substantial extra costs, and does no longer meet the expectations of consumers, who more and more expect naturally derived, clean-label food and beverages without artificial blending [2]. At this point, fermentation offers an appealing option to naturally increase nutritional quality and taste of plant-based milk. In particular, mono-culture fermentation of plant-based materials is well established and has been used to increase e.g. vitamin B12 levels [22,23,24]. Often, however, fermentative synthesis of the vitamin is enabled by undesired non-natural supplementation of precursors and supporting agents [1, 24,25,26,27].

In this work, we developed a novel co-culture process for natural fermentation of sunflower seed milk to increase the vitamin B12 level. An initial screening round identified potential strains of Propionibacterium freudenreichii, which displays the only generally regarded as safe (GRAS) approved bacterium, known to synthesize active B12 [22], for fermentative production of the vitamin in sunflower seed milk. Subsequently, metabolic activities of the best performing strain P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 were analysed and provided a detailed signature profile. Bacillus amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 and Lactocaseibacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511, two microbes recently found well-performing in plant milk fermentation [28], revealed rather complementary features suggesting to co-culture them with the Propionibacterium to promote its growth and vitamin B12 biosynthetic power. After iterative optimization rounds, co-cultures of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 were identified as the best set up. Co-cultivation of the two strains in sunflower seed milk increased the level of vitamin B12 up to 17 µg (100 g)−1, almost eight-fold more than initially observed for the Propionibacterium alone. Furthermore, the co-culture increased the levels of vitamins B3 and B6, and the essential amino acid l-lysine, improved the protein digestibility corrected amino acid score (PDCAAS), decreased indigestible carbohydrate levels, and improved flavor. The developed co-culture approach seems valuable to upgrade sunflower seed milk and potentially also other plant milk materials.


Evaluation of food-grade propionibacteria for their vitamin B12 production capacity

In an initial round of experiments, food-grade strains of P. freudenreichii were screened in MRS medium for their suitability to synthetize and secrete vitamin B12. Because anaerobic conditions seemed crucial to grow the cells [29], while aerobic conditions had proven beneficial to support vitamin B12 biosynthesis [30], dual phase cultures were conducted. After two days of anaerobic fermentation, the cells were shifted to aerobic conditions for another day. All strains formed the desired vitamin (Fig. 1A), whereby the B12 level ranged between 6.4 and 21.8 µg (100 g)−1. Vitamin B12 production in MRS medium was enhanced up to almost 150 µg (100 g)−1 by the addition of CoCl2 (50 µM) and DMBI (100 µM). Interestingly, the strains differed quite substantially in the extent, to which B12 production was activated by the stimulant mixture. Based on the data, five strains appeared most interesting: P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 (the best producer in supplemented MRS medium), NCC 1138 (the best producer in basic MRS medium), NCC 1197 and NCC 1186 (two strains with pronounced activation potential), and P. freudenreichii DSM 4902 (previously reported to be a vitamin B12 producer) [22].

Fig. 1
figure 1

Screening of food-grade strains of P. freudenreichii for vitamin B12 synthesis. The data comprise the final titer of vitamin B12 in basic MRS medium and in MRS medium, supplemented with 50 µM CoCl2 and 100 µM dimethylbenzimidazole (DMBI) (A). In addition, pH, and growth of selected P. freudenreichii strains in MRS medium (B), and vitamin B12 production and growth of selected P. freudenreichii strains in pasteurized sunflower seed milk medium is shown (C). P. freudenreichii DSM 4902 was used as a positive control. The process was carried out as dual phase cultivation with an initial anaerobic phase (48 h), followed by an aerobic phase (24 h). n = 3

To better understand the needs and capabilities of these strains, we assessed cell growth, residual glucose, and final pH value. It turned out that the strains differed in glucose utilisation. Four strains did not completely use up the sugar (1.04 g L−1 contained in the MRS medium) but left over a fraction of 37% (NCC 1177), 40% (DSM 4902), 43% (NCC 1197), and even 70% (NCC 1138). This limited capacity was likely due to an inhibiting acidification of the medium to a pH value around 4.9 – 5.5 (Fig. 1B). In contrast, strain NCC 1186 appeared more acid tolerant. Its medium pH dropped to 3.9 while glucose was fully depleted which corresponded to the fact that this strain reached the highest cfu number. Taken together, it seemed that the observed differences in vitamin B12 production were not simply due to differences in growth. As example, NCC 1186, yielded much less of the vitamin than NCC 1177, despite better pH tolerance, sugar uptake, and growth. Based on the data, the five strains were taken further to assess their capability to produce vitamin B12 in sunflower seed milk.

Sunflower seed milk composition

Sunflower seed milk was prepared as aqueous solution of defatted sunflower seed flour. Batches at small scale were prepared by sterilization of the milk using low-pressure-pasteurization (LPP). This procedure provided a sterile, homogenous suspension. Protein represented the largest fraction (57.6% w/w dry mass), followed by soluble carbohydrates (9.3%), and only a low share of fat (0.8%) (Fig. 2A). The remaining fraction (32.3%) was attributed to e. g. fibres, ash, and salt. The most abundant non-essential amino acids were L-glutamate (12.6%) and L-aspartate (5.4%). The major essential amino acids were L-leucine (3.8%) and L-valine (3.0%). Soluble carbohydrates comprised digestible (sucrose) and indigestible sugars (raffinose, stachyose). Hereby, sucrose (7.2%) and raffinose (2.9%) showed the highest level, while stachyose was present in low amount (0.2%). L-Lysine was the most limiting essential amino acid. Related to the protein content, the level of L-lysine was 40 mg (g protein)−1, which represented only 69% of the FAO recommended value for children of 58 mg (g protein)−1 [31].

Fig. 2
figure 2

Composition of lab-scale pasteurized sunflower seed milk and ultra-high-temperature processed sunflower seed milk. All values are related to the dry mass (w/w). n = 3

In addition, the milk was also ultra-pasteurized at ultrahigh temperature and pressure to represent industrially preferred treatment [32]. We therefore processed a 50 kg batch of UHT sunflower seed milk at pilot scale, including pre-warming to 75 °C, heating to 143 °C for 4 s, followed by efficient cooling. Overall, the chemical composition of UHT sunflower seed milk was comparable to that of LPP sunflower seed milk (Fig. 2B). Visual inspection revealed a less brownish color of the UHT plant milk, indicating less pronounced Maillard reactions by the shorter heating.

P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 performs best in sunflower seed milk among a panel of tested strains

The five most promising strains from the screening (Fig. 1A, B) were now evaluated in the milk. When cultivated in sunflower seed milk for three days—two days under anaerobic conditions, followed by one day under aerobic conditions—strain NCC 1177 showed by far the best performance (Fig. 1C). The microbe produced 2.4 µg (100 g)−1 vitamin B12. In quantitative terms, NCC 1177 accumulated 160% more of the vitamin than NCC 1138, the second-best strain, and up to threefold more than the other three strains. NCC 1177 was also the best grower, as indicated by the high level of living cells. For NCC 1186, weak growth appeared somewhat linked to insignificant vitamin B12 formation. The other three strains were medium growers and medium B12 producers. The observed differences indicated that growth and B12 production in the milk were linked. As example, NCC 1177 produced 2.5-fold more vitamin B12 than NCC 1197, while reaching a twofold higher cfu number. This observation suggested that good growth in the milk seemed, at least, one prerequisite for high vitamin B12 levels. The best-performing strain, NCC 1177, was selected for further studies.

Vitamin B12 biosynthesis of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 in sunflower seed milk is limited by a lack of accessible carbon sources and B12 precursors

Next, we elucidated the potential to stimulate vitamin B12 production of strain NCC 1177 in sunflower seed milk. We tested supplementation with cobalt and DMBI, given their positive effects on vitamin B12 synthesis in MRS medium (Fig. 1A). Furthermore, we tested a range of other supporting ingredients, namely the DMBI precursor riboflavin (vitamin B2), nicotinamide (vitamin B3), previously shown to catalytically enhance DMBI formation [15], different amino acids, incorporated during vitamin B12 biosynthesis (l-threonine, l-glutamate, and glycine), and succinate as donor for succinyl-CoA at the start of the B12 pathway. In addition, glucose and lactate were tested as carbon sources to stimulate growth of the Propionibacterium and thereby enhance the growth-associated vitamin B12 biosynthesis [26, 33].

The addition of cobalt did not have an impact on vitamin B12 synthesis (Additional file 1: Table S2A). In addition, growth remained unchanged as well. Likewise, the extra addition of 50 µm CoCl2 to the MRS pre-culture medium to eventually pre-load the cells with cobalt for better performance did not reveal any stimulating effect (Additional file 1: Table S2B) neither did have the effect of higher concentrations of cobalt (Additional file 1: Table S2B). Obviously, the natural cobalt level of the plant milk (8 µg/kg) was sufficient. Supplementation of the milk with riboflavin (vitamin B2) increased vitamin B12 production by more than 20%, whereas DMBI and nicotinamide addition had no effect. Notably, lactate and glucose were found highly beneficial as extra carbon sources. Their addition resulted in 2.4-fold and 1.4-fold more vitamin B12, whereby growth of NCC 1177 was markedly increased. In contrast, a mixture of l-threonine, l-glutamate, glycine, and succinate, added at a low level to check for a growth-decoupled contribution to the B12 pathway itself, did not trigger vitamin B12 production. A combination of all supplements worked best. The mixture resulted in a more than five-fold increased vitamin B12 level, 12.3 µg (100 g−1) and much better growth, indicating additive effects (Additional file 1: Table S2A).

Metabolic profiling unravels the lifestyle of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and its capabilities and inabilities in sunflower seed milk fermentation

At this stage, it appeared important to study the lifestyle of strain NCC 1177 in more detail and identify the specific needs of the microbe. Cultures of the microbe in sunflower seed milk were conducted under (micro) aerobic (24 h) and under anaerobic (48 h) conditions and analyzed for cell growth and changes in various metabolites: sugars, organic acids, amino acids, and vitamins. Non-inoculated milk, incubated under the same conditions, served as a control. Under anaerobic conditions, NCC 1177 grew well from 107 to almost 109 cfu’s (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3). The strain formed 0.9 µg (100 g)−1 vitamin B12. Interestingly, the microbe had a strong demand for biotin (vitamin B7) but did not touch niacin (vitamin B3), also present. Furthermore, strain NCC 1177 did not efficiently consume the available sugars. It was not able to utilize sucrose, the most abundant sugar, and consumed only minor shares of raffinose and stachyose. Likewise, the acetate level remained largely constant. Lactate, an otherwise suitable carbon source was not available in the sunflower seed milk (Additional file 1: Table S3). Instead, growth of NCC 1177 seemed to rely on selected amino acids: l-isoleucine, l-alanine, l-serine, glycine, l-proline, and most strongly l-aspartate were consumed, well matching the catabolic amino acid spectrum of the microbe [34]. Propionic acid was observed as prominent by-product, and its occurrence nicely reflected the fermentative routes present in amino acid-grown propionibacteria [34, 35]. These microbes yield propionic acid from amino acids such as l-aspartate via the Wood-Werkman cycle to generate ATP and regenerate oxidized co-enzymes [36].

Fig. 3
figure 3

Metabolic signature profile of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 during aerobic and anaerobic cultivation of pasteurized sunflower seed milk. The data shown display the most relevant characteristics regarding growth, the content of vitamins, sugars, organic acids, amino acids, and flavor formation. The changes of metabolite levels are given as relative values. For each parameter, the maximum absolute concentration change (increase or decrease), observed among all conditions, was set to a value of 1. The changes of the other conditions were normalized to this maximum to allow a straightforward comparison. All corresponding absolute values are provided in Additional file 1: Table S3, whereby the maximum change, used for the normalization is highlighted. In addition, the starting values for non-fermented milk are shown. The fermentation was carried out at 30°C either anaerobically (48 h) or aerobically (24 h). n = 3

In comparison, growth under aerobic conditions was much weaker. Likewise, only a rather small amount of vitamin B12 was formed. Dissolved oxygen was available during the whole cultivation (Additional file 1: Fig. S2A). The amino acids l-aspartate and l-proline seemed the main growth substrates. Raffinose and stachyose were partially consumed, while sucrose and acetate were not used. Regarding other B vitamins, B7 was required and B12 was formed. The pH value remained relatively stable during the entire cultivation. One could conclude at this point that growth of the Propionibacterium in the presence of oxygen suffered from its weak capability to use the organic compounds in the sunflower seed milk as growth substrate. It goes without saying that anaerobic conditions were found optimal.

B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 emerge as potential partners for co-cultures

We now wondered: could another microbe cover the specific needs of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177? Recently, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 were identified as well-performing strains for chickpea milk fermentation [28]. Although this outcome was based on a different raw material, the multiple benefits discovered for the two strains (broad substrate range, production of essential amino acids, removal of indigestible sugars) appeared appealing to test them as potential partners for the Propionibacterium. To this end, they were both cultivated in sunflower seed milk, once under aerobic and once under anaerobic conditions.

B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 performed best under aerated conditions (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3). The strain exhibited strong growth (from 107 to 109 cfu’s) and efficiently utilized all major sugars—sucrose, raffinose, and stachyose. Interestingly, it accumulated significant amounts of vitamins B3 and B7 (Fig. 3). Furthermore, the microbe formed substantial levels of free amino acids (Additional file 1: Table S3). Due to the obviously high oxygen demand of B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, the dissolved oxygen level sharply decreased to 0% within 5 h and remained low until the end of the process (Additional file 1: Fig. S2C). The pH value dropped from 5.8 to 4.9 after 10 h and increased back to the starting value afterwards. Under anaerobic conditions, growth of NCC 156 was diminished. The strain fermented small amounts of sucrose (2.0 mM), stachyose (0.5 mM) and raffinose (0.1 mM), mainly into lactate (1.6 mM) and acetate (1.2 mM) (Additional file 1: Table S3). Vitamins were accumulated, although much less than in the aerated process.

In comparison L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 grew almost equally well under both conditions (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3). Under aerobic conditions, it degraded all three sugars and formed lactate as main by-product plus acetate. The pH value slightly decreased slightly from 5.8 to 5.5, whereas the dissolved oxygen level remained almost at full saturation (Additional file 1: Fig. S2B). Moreover, NCC 2511 exhibited a need for vitamin B7, and largely consumed free amino acids. The most pronounced differences, observed under anaerobic conditions, comprised a shift in substrate use from sugars to amino acids. Again, lactate and acetate were the major products formed.

Neither B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 nor L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511, of course, formed vitamin B12 under any condition.

Evaluation of double and triple co-cultures highlights P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 as perfect synergistic partners

As shown, the metabolic signatures of the different microbes appeared highly complementary. As example, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 formed lactate, free amino acids, and vitamin B7, which were apparently all utilized by the Propionibacterium (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3). NCC 156 furthermore supplied vitamin B3, potentially stimulating B12 production (Additional file 1: Table S3). NCC 2511 formed lactate too. These patterns provoked an interesting question. Could co-culturing of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 with the Bacillus and/or the Lactocaseibacillus enhance its growth and eventually boost vitamin B12 production? Therefore, P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 was co-cultured in LPP sunflower seed milk with each strain individually (double co-cultures) and with both strains together (triple co-culture). Like the initial studies, the 72-h cultures comprised two phases, an initial anaerobic phase (48 h), followed by an aerobic phase (24 h).

Grown together with P. freudenreichii NCC 1177, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 improved vitamin B12 production by the Propionibacterium remarkably (Fig. 4A). In both co-cultures that contained the Bacillus, the final level of the vitamin was around 9 µg (100 g)−1, almost four-fold higher than in the fermentation with the Propionibacterium alone. The boost in vitamin B12 observed in the co-culture was almost as high as observed for NCC 1177 upon full supplementation with cobalt, various precursors, and biosynthetic stimulants (Additional file 1: Table S2A).

Fig. 4
figure 4

Performance of co-cultures on sunflower seed milk. The data comprise time-resolved changes for P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 (column 1), a dual co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 (inoculated at 1:1 ratio, column 2), a dual co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 (inoculated at 1000:1 ratio, column 3), and a triple co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 (inoculated at 500:500:1 ratio, column 4). Shown are vitamin B12 content (A), living cell number (B), sugar content (C), organic acid content (D), extracellular amino acid content (E), total amino acid content (F), and protein quality (G), expressed as in vitro protein digestibility corrected amino acid score (PDCAAS). The cultivation was carried out at 30 °C for 72 h, including an initial 48 h anaerobic phase, followed by a 24 h aerobic phase. n = 3

How did B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 boost vitamin B12 production? Clearly, it stimulated growth of the Propionibacterium during both phases of the fermentation. The latter achieved a tenfold higher cfu level by the presence of NCC 156 (Fig. 4B). This effect was observable in the double and the triple culture in which the strains were combined. First, NCC 156 formed lactate, a readily available carbon source for NCC 1177. Lactate itself was not detectable in the mixed cultures which let us to conclude that the entire amount that accumulated in anaerobic cultures of NCC 156 (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3), was completely re-consumed by the Propionibacterium in the co-culture. Second, NCC 156 provided a rich spectrum of free amino acids that displayed easily accessible carbon for the vitamin B12 producer (Fig. 4E). NCC 156 furthermore supplied vitamin B3, potentially stimulating B12 production (Fig. 3, Additional file 1: Table S3).

In addition, sunflower seed milk, fermented by the two-strain combination, was largely depleted of the indigestible sugars raffinose and stachyose (Fig. 4C, and the overall content of amino acids was substantially enhanced (Fig. 4F). The PDCAAS was 0.63, approximately 7% higher than that of all other fermented milks and that of the native plant milk (Fig. 4G).

Subsequent experiments aimed at optimizing the performance of this promising two-strain combination. Hereby, the inoculum ratio was identified as crucial parameter. A 1,000-fold excess of Propionibacterium over Bacillus cells resulted in a marked improvement of vitamin B12 production, whereby growth itself was not affected (Additional file 1: Table S4).

In contrast, L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 did not improve vitamin B12 production, when added. It neither stimulated the Propionibacterium directly nor provided an indirect benefit in the triple co-culture.

Scaling the collaboration between P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 to pilot scale processed sunflower seed milk

Among all tested combinations, the co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 seemed to work the best. It achieved the highest level of vitamin B12, the lowest level of indigestible sugars and the highest protein quality score—and thereby required only three things: natural sunflower seed milk and the two microbes. It was therefore selected for further optimization.

The fermentation capacity of the co-culture of NCC 1177 and NCC 156 was now compared for the differently pre-treated milks, the LPP and the UHT processed one respectively, again using the workflow of three days (two days anaerobic and one day aerobic incubation). Notably, the co-culture performed excellent in UHT milk and yielded almost 40% more vitamin B12 than the lab scale LPP milk, i. e. a final level of 13 versus 9 µg (100 g)−1 (Fig. 5A). A possible reason might have been the more beneficial content of free amino acids by the UHT treatment (Additional file 1: Table S3 and S5).

Fig. 5
figure 5

Impact of raw material pre-processing and inoculation ratio on the fermentation of sunflower seed milk by a co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156. Production of vitamin B12 on low pressure pasteurized (LPP) and ultra-high temperature (UHT) treated milk (A). Impact of the fermentation set-up with varied aerobic and anaerobic phases on cell growth and vitamin B12 production (B). Impact of the ratio between the strains on vitamin B12 production (C). For the latter, the numbers reflect the cfu ratio between NCC 1177 and NCC 156 at the end of the process. n = 3

Making the collaboration between P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 more successful: tuning of aeration and fermentation time

Next, the influence of the dissolved oxygen level (during the second aerobic phase of the fermentation process) was evaluated. It turned out that a balanced oxygen supply was crucial to achieve a high vitamin B12 content (Fig. 6A). Too little aeration resulted in up to 26% lower titers, but too strong oxygen supply also reduced production. Furthermore, the oxygen supply influenced growth of both microbes, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 and P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 (Fig. 6B), and the production of the vitamins B2, B3, and B6 (Fig. 6D), indicating a complex interplay. The specific vitamin B12 production per single cell, estimated from the data, revealed that NCC 1177 was most productive without oxygen exposure (Fig. 6C). However, also high oxygen supply resulted in good performance. Under these conditions, growth of B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 was strongest. The microbe supplied elevated levels of vitamins B2 and B3, known to stimulate B12 formation [14, 15]. Overall, the oxygen influence on vitamin B12 production appeared complex. It likely stimulated growth of NCC 1177 and NCC 156 but also activated the B12 biosynthetic pathway itself. One piece of the underlying complexity is the response of P. freudenreichii to oxygen. The microbe is known to be anerobic to aerotolerant [37], grows best anaerobically but is capable to generate energy also under microaerobic conditions using the TCA cycle and functional electron transport chains [38,39,40,41]. Due to the huge optimization potential of supplying the right amount of oxygen, it appears relevant to resolve this picture on the metabolic level in more detail in the future. Clearly, oxygen availability emerged as crucial factor to boost performance.

Fig. 6
figure 6

Impact of the dissolved oxygen level on the fermentation of sunflower seed milk by a co-culture of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156. Impact of oxygen supply on vitamin B12 production (A), growth (B), vitamin B12 production per cell (C), and the production of vitamins B1, B2, B3, B6, and B7 during fermentation (D). Prior to fermentation, the milk was processed by ultra-high temperature treatment. The different aeration regimes from low to high (shown from left to right) were created by incubation in non-baffled flasks at 80 rpm, baffled flasks at 80 rpm, non-baffled flasks at 130 rpm, baffled flasks at 130 rpm, non-baffled flasks at 180 rpm and baffled flasks at 180 rpm. The inoculum ratio between strains NCC 1177 and NCC 156 was 1000:1. Fermentation was carried out at 30 °C for 72 h, including an initial 48 h anaerobic phase, followed by a 24 h aerobic phase. n = 3

Optimum vitamin B12 production was as high as 14.8 µg (100 g)−1 and occurred under three different aeration regimes, indicating a robust process window. Finally, we tested different set-ups, regarding the duration of the process (Fig. 5B). A slightly prolonged aerobic fermentation phase allowed to increase vitamin B12 production even further. Notably, it the vitamin B12 level of the fermented sunflower seed milk appeared proportional to the inoculation ratio between P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 (Fig. 5C, r = 0.80). A dual phase fermentation with two days anaerobic and then two days aerobic incubation resulted in almost 16 µg (100 g)−1 vitamin B12. Similarly in performance was a three-plus-two-day setup.

Metabolic interplay between P. freudenreichii and B. amyloliquefaciens

The optimized process was now studied over 96 h, regarding the dynamics of strain growth, and the content of sugars, amino acids, organic acids, vitamins, and flavor compounds (Additional file 1: Fig. S3). The co-cultivation included a 2-day anaerobic phase, followed by a 2-day aerobic phase. Sunflower seed milk appeared best in composition after 80 h (Fig. 7). The initial anaerobic phase was the major growth phase of NCC 1177. After inoculation, the Propionibacterium immediately started to proliferate, and its cfu number increased about 30-fold over the first 48 h (Fig. 7A). Cells of NCC 156 multiplied almost 100-fold during the first 24 h. Notably, growth of NCC 156 resulted in an increased level of vitamin B7 (29.4%), which was afterwards consumed by NCC 1177 (Fig. 7C). In addition, the PDCAAS was slightly improved (14%) (Fig. 7H). Propionate (3.9 mM), acetoin (3.5 mM), and acetate (3.1 mM) were the major fermentation by-products during the anaerobic phase (Fig. 7G). An interesting picture resulted for the substrates. Sucrose was consumed from early on (by NCC 156, because NCC 1177 could not use it). Between 30 and 48 h, however, the sucrose level remained constant, while raffinose started to be consumed. The metabolization of this trisaccharide involves enzymatic cleavage into sucrose and galactose [42]. The constant sucrose level therefore resulted from a superposition of sucrose release from the cleavage of raffinose and (the probably) on-going sucrose consumption by NCC 156. Galactose was directly consumed, as it could not be detected. The sugar displays well-accessible carbon for B. amyloliquefaciens [43], explaining this observation. As shown for the monoculture, the fermentation of sucrose and galactose by B. amyloliquefaciens yielded lactate (Fig. 3). However, different to the monoculture, the organic acid was not observed in the co-culture. We conclude that lactate was immediately taken up as preferred carbon source by the Propionibacterium. In addition, the Propionibacterium used a range of amino acids during this stage (Additional file 1: Table S5).

Fig. 7
figure 7

Dynamics of co-culture fermentation of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 on UHT pre-treated sunflower seed milk. The data comprise living cell number (cfu) (A), vitamin B12 (B), vitamin B3, B6, and B7 (C), the area of favored and unfavored volatile (D), sucrose, raffinose, and stachyose (E), extracellular l-lysine, l-leucine, l-tryptophan, and l-methionine (F), acetoin, 2,3-butanediol, propionate, and acetate (G), PDCAAS (H). The phases of anaerobic (I) and aerobic (II) incubation are indicated in the time profile. The groups of favored and non-favored volatiles were assigned from the flavor properties of the individual compounds (see legend of Fig. 8). n = 3

Moreover, the anaerobic fermentation beneficially changed the flavor profile (Fig. 7D). With the onset of aeration after 48 h, the metabolism of the co-culture immediately changed. Growth of NCC 156 was strongly stimulated. NCC 1177 continued to grow, and the number of living cells increased once more about tenfold (Fig. 7A).

Notably, the aerobic phase was the major phase of vitamin B12 production. After 80 h, the vitamin had reached a high level of 15.2 (µg·100 g−1) (Fig. 7B). Notably, also other B vitamins were formed including vitamin B3 (0.5 mg·100 g−1) and vitamin B6 (70 µg·100 g−1) (Fig. 7C). Now, NCC 156 quickly consumed sucrose. From 60 h on, co-consumption of the disaccharide together with raffinose and stachyose was observed (Fig. 7E). When sucrose was depleted (66 h), propionate, acetoin, and 2,3-butanediol started to get consumed (Fig. 7G), while raffinose and stachyose degradation continued (Fig. 7E). The transient increase of the raffinose level seemed due to the onset of stachyose metabolism. Like raffinose, the tetrasaccharide stachyose belongs to the raffinose oligosaccharide family. It yields raffinose plus galactose during initial cleavage [42]. Regarding propionate, certain Bacillus strains can use it as a carbon source but B. amyloliquefaciens cannot [44]. In fact, the Propionibacterium re-used its own previously synthetized propionate, as also observed in the monoculture (Fig. 4). In the absence of other substrates, propionic acid is metabolized by P. freudenreichii using the reversed Wood–Werkman cycle [45]. This seemed the case here: NCC 1177 could not use the remaining sugars and lactate (one of its preferred carbon sources) was no more available, because NCC 156 did not form it under aerobic conditions (Fig. 4). Therefore, the Propionibacterium had to rely on organic acids or amino acids instead.

Overall, the co-fermentation showed an outstanding capacity to degrade indigestible sugars: raffinose (78.2%) and stachyose (78.8%) were largely depleted. Acetate (25.8 mM) was the major organic acid after 80 h. Remarkably, free extracellular amino acids, including l-lysine, l-methionine, and l-tryptophan, essential amino acids that are often limited in plant-based materials, increased during the final cultivation phase (Fig. 7F). This accumulation improved the PDCAAS to 0.66 (Fig. 7H). The amount of favoured flavor compounds (inferred from the total peak area during GC/MS analysis) increased three-fold during the aerobic phase, while unfavoured volatiles were reduced by 90.6% (Fig. 7D). A continuation of the fermentation process to finally 96 h, resulted in an even higher vitamin B12 level, 17.0 µg (100 g−1), as well as increased levels of vitamin B2, and extracellular amino acids. However, the prolongation of the process to 96 h somewhat decreased flavor value and the PDCAAS (Additional file 1: Fig. S3).

Impact of fermentation on flavor development

GC–MS-based analysis revealed a strong impact of the co-culture on the spectrum of flavor related volatiles (Fig. 8). In total, 34 volatiles were identified in unfermented and fermented sunflower seed milk, including various saturated and unsaturated organic alcohols, aldehydes, ketones, organic acids, terpenoid, lactones, and furans. In unfermented sunflower seed milk, 1-hexanal and 2-pentyl-furan, which are volatiles with grassy and beany flavor, dominated, while sweet and fruity aroma compounds (e. g. 2-heptanone, β-terpinen, p-cymene, and D-lemonene) were present in lower amount. Co-cultures with P. freudenreichii and B. amyloliquefaciens changed the flavor profile significantly (Fig. 8). Several valuable volatiles were generated after 24 h, such as acetoin, 1-pentanol, allo-ocimene, limonene oxide, acetic acid, propionic acid, 1-octanol, 2-nonanone, trans-2-dodecanal, isopinocarveol, and 1-haptanol. After switching to aerobic conditions (48 h–72 h), acetoin and 2,3-butanediol, yielding buttery and fruity notes, were formed. Notably, the largest area of favoured volatiles was detected after 72 h fermentation. Unfavoured compounds such as hexanal and 2-pentyl-furan were completely removed after 48 h and 72 h of fermentation, respectively.

Fig. 8
figure 8

Flavor formation of food-grade microbes during sunflower seed milk fermentation. The data for flavor volatiles reflect the change in abundance in comparison to non-fermented sunflower seed milk (control). Classification into favored volatiles with flora, fruity, sweet, and creamy aroma properties (yellow), neutral volatiles with concentration dependent desired and non-desired aroma properties (light blue), and unfavored volatiles,potentially contributing to the beany, green, and mushroom flavor (dark blue) relates to previous dedicated studies and databases on odor and taste [82,83,84,85,86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93,94,95,96,97]. RT = retention time. The flavor properties are taken from previous studies and databases: A [82], B [83], C [84], D [85], E [86], F [87], G [88], H [89], I[90], J [91], K [92], L [93], M [94], N[95], O [96], P [97]. n = 3


Industrial impact of naturally fermented sunflower seed milk, rich in vitamin B12

As shown, co-fermentation of two carefully selected food-grade microbes provided sunflower seed milk which contained up to 17 µg (100 g)−1 vitamin B12, accompanied by concurrently increased levels of vitamins B3 and B6, improved protein quality and flavor profile, and strongly reduced amounts of indigestible sugars.

Vitamin B12 is one of the most important micronutrients for the human body but is unfavorably absent from plant-derived food [21], including sunflower seed milk. Therefore, vegetarians can face vitamin B12 deficiency regardless of their demographic characteristics, place of residency, age, and type of vegetarian diet [21]. Vitamin B12 deficiency can have severe consequences. It leads to increased homocysteine levels in the blood, a recognized risk factor for atherothrombotic and neuropsychiatric disorders [12, 21]. Of specific impact at this moment, vitamin B12, due to its various health benefits, seems to be a supporting active ingredient against COVID-19 symptoms and SARS-CoV-2 infections [46]. As example, methyl-cobalamin supplements help to reduce COVID-19-related organ damage and other symptoms [47]. A clinical study conducted in Singapore showed reduced COVID-19 symptoms in patients who received a daily supplementation with vitamin B12, vitamin D, and magnesium, reducing the need for oxygen and intensive care support [48].

Altogether, the demand for safe and cost-effective dietary nutrition with elevated vitamin B12 levels sharply increases. According to European Union food regulations, the recommended daily uptake (RDA) for vitamin B12 is 2.5 µg [49]. Hence, a single daily serving of 100 mL of our fermented sunflower seed milk would deliver up to sixfold of the RDA level for vitamin B12, far more than the minimum value required to claim: “high in content” (> 30% RDA). The vitamin B12 level [17 µg (100 g−1)] is among the highest values, achieved by supplement-free fermentation of plant-based materials. This achievement makes microbially co-cultured sunflower seed milk a promising alternative to animal-derived foods such as milk [0.4 µg (100 g−1)], eggs [1.4 µg (100 g−1)], lean red meat [3 µg (100 g−1)], and fish [2 µg (100 g−1)] [21] to provide vitamin B12.

Fermentation provides sunflower seed milk with multiple benefits

Though numerous innovative food beverages from plant sources are being exploited as animal milk alternatives, many of these face some/any type of nutritional and organoleptic issues [2, 50]. Above all, the major reasons impeding the consumer’s interests and application of plant-based milks are: (i) inferior nutrient value limited by vitamin content and protein quality; (ii) poor digestibility due to the existence of indigestible compounds and anti-nutrients which may cause flatulence, diarrhoea, and other symptoms; (iii) off-flavor and taste such as beany, bitter, and earthy flavor associated to the raw materials. In this regard, appropriate multi-purpose strains and strain combinations appear crucial for upgrading these materials. It is therefore an important outcome of this study that P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 addressed several of the key requirements, partly alone but optimally in combination. Both strains showed robust growth in sunflower seed milk. P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 produced vitamin B12 (Additional file 1: Table S3), whereas B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 increased the l-lysine level and the overall protein quality, produced vitamins B2, B3, B7, and decreased indigestible sugars (Fig. 3). Likewise, strain NCC 156 provided several benefits in recent study on chickpea milk: increased levels of l-lysine, increased protein quality, decreased levels of indigestible sugars, and improved flavor profile [28], indicating that this strain works in different plant milks. Process control might help to prevent overgrowth of this fast-growing strain, where needed.

Here, the two well-performing isolates stand in a prominent line with related microbes, applied in plant-based fermentation and recognized as probiotics [23, 51]. Strains of P. freudenreichii were shown to synthetize vitamin B12 on plant-based materials such as barley (0.9–3.7 μg 100 g−1) [52], wheat (around 2.6–4.5 μg 100 g−1) [24, 53], durum (1.3 μg 100 g−1) [53], lupin (6.0 µg 100 g−1) [54], sauerkraut, and vegetable juice (7.2 μg 100 g−1) [55]. In addition, strains of B. amyloliquefaciens proved value regarding flavor formation and the hydrolysis of plant protein, the release of peptides, and the generation of bioactive compound and vitamins [56].

It is worth noting that as a monoculture, Propionibacterium needs a quite long fermentation time (up to 7 days or even longer) for optimized vitamin B12 production [22, 23, 26, 27]. In this study, we were able to shorten the fermentation time to 3 or 4 days, which is more efficient for industrial application. Moreover, our development comes with even more commercial benefits: improved flavor, improved digestibility, improved protein quality, and elevated levels of vitamins B3 and B6. The two strains NCC 1177 and NCC 156 are natural isolates, generally recognized as safe to be used in food fermentation[57]. Furthermore, no additives were used. The fermentation process contained only three ingredients: sunflower seed flour, the food-grade microbes, and water, enabling “clean labelling” as expected by consumers. Taken together, the developed co-culture fermentation displays a valuable development for human nutrition.

P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 exhibit fine-tuned functional interactions

In the optimized co-culture fermentation process, several synergistic effects could be detected: (i) both strains showed better growth; (ii) vitamin B12 production of P. freudenreichii increased more than sevenfold as compared to mono-fermentation (17.0 µg 100 g−1); (iii) the PDCAAS was improved (29%), (iv) the level of l-lysine, the most limiting essential amino acid, was increased by 43%, (iv) the level of vitamins B3 (0.5 mg 100 g−1) and B6 (70 µg 100 g−1) was increased, and (v) the overall flavor profile was improved. Without doubt, the rich spectrum of benefits originated from microbial collaboration.

From a biochemical perspective, successful synthesis of vitamin B12 relies on several factors. First, and important to note here, vitamin B12 production in P. freudenreichii (including strain NCC 1177) is growth associated, making accessible and growth-promoting substrates one of the determinants [26]. Furthermore, cobalt and DMBI drive B12 production [27], while l-glutamate, glycine, l-threonine, and succinyl-CoA display the building blocks of the vitamin [58]. Earlier studies with P. freudenreichii cell homogenates showed that DMBI was derived from vitamin B2 (riboflavin) [59] and that the biosynthesis process was stimulated by vitamin B3 (nicotinamide) [15]. Here, we obtained a complex picture when trying out the effect of supplements on vitamin B12 production by NCC 1177 during sunflower seed fermentation. As shown, the addition of lactose, glucose, and riboflavin boosted vitamin B12 formation, while cobalt, DMBI, nicotinamide, l-glutamate, glycine, l-threonine, and succinate did not. These findings implied that major limiting factors were weak growth of Propionibacterium and low availability of vitamin B2. A combination of all supplements resulted in a more than five-fold increased vitamin B12 level, indicating the benefits of a more fine-tuned synergy regarding growth and supplementation.

On basis of the elaborated microbe’s physiology, growth and vitamin B12 biosynthesis were limited by several factors: (i) P. freudenreichii could only use extracellular amino acids but none of the sugars present in sunflower seed milk (Fig. 3); (ii) P. freudenreichii required micronutrients such as biotin to grow (Fig. 3) [60]; (iii) the microbe formed propionic acid causing an inhibiting pH decrease [61]; (iv) vitamin B12 biosynthesis was limited by insufficient availability of vitamin B2. Considering these requirements, B. amyloliquefaciens emerged as a perfect partner for P. freudenreichii, providing a natural dual culture consortium, co-working for improved growth, and finally yielding a multi-benefit fermentation. Proven interactions during the first phase included the donation of accessible carbon and essential micronutrients by NCC 156, stimulating growth of NCC 1177. During the second (aerobic) phase of the fermentation, B. amyloliquefaciens quickly proliferated. It released free amino acids from the protein and eventually lowered the dissolved oxygen level in a beneficial way, further stimulating growth of P. freudenreichii. In this regard, the ability of the Bacillus to form carbohydrases and proteinases and provide accessible carbon appeared crucial. At the same time, the Bacillus produced vitamin B2, vitamin B3, and vitamin B7, directly supporting vitamin B12 synthesis. We conclude that microbial cooperation more than compensates for a lack in key nutrients and adverse physicochemical conditions in plant-based materials, given that well-collaborating microbes are put together. Their careful selection and combination, as shown here, appears crucial for the success.

As shown, co-fermentation of NCC 156 and NCC 1177 was strikingly superior to that of the single strains. It stands in line with a range of successful co-fermentations, reported previously for food manufacturing, for example to produce yogurt, wine, and aroma-rich cocoa beans [62,63,64]. Co-fermentation of P. freudenreichii with the fungus Rhizopus oryzae on lupin tempeh yielded 20-fold more vitamin B12 than P. freudenreichii alone. Interestingly, the major interaction between these two microbes was hydrolysis of the seed protein by R. oryzae, releasing free amino acids to support growth of P. freudenreichii [54]. Propionibacterium also showed increased capacity to produce vitamin B12, when co-fermented with Rhizopus oligosporus on soybean [65], with kefir grains [66], and with different lactobacilli in wheat bran [24], soybean [65], and whey [25, 27, 67]. However, no synergistic effects on vitamin B12 production could be unraveled, when mixing Propionibacterium with lactobacilli [67].


In this work, a genomic and metabolomic approach enabled the knowledge-based assembly of a consortium of food grade microbes for upgrading of sunflower seed milk, derived from sunflower press cakes as a waste product during sunflower oil production. This plant-based material offers the concept of sustainability and circular economy, when used for human consumption, and is therefore considered particularly eco-friendly in the strongly developing market of plant-based food [68]. As shown, the interactions between B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 and P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 enabled a co-operative process with remarkable benefits: (i) enriched content of vitamin B12, the key micronutrient for all vegans to be aware of, (ii) improved digestibility due to the removal of raffinose and stachyose, increased protein quality with increased levels of the most limiting essential amino acid l-lysine, and (iv) an improved flavor profile due the elimination of bitter notes and the generation of sweet and fruity aromas.

Notably, the key to the successful process was microbial collaboration. The excellent co-working of the strains even enabled a completely natural process without any supplementation. Inferred from the process data of the co-culture between 48 and 65 h (Fig. 7), a single cell of Propionibacterium synthetized up to 100 molecules of B12 per second which displays a remarkable synthetic power, considering the complexity of the vitamin.

Nature demonstrates the power of successful collaboration for complex tasks. Notably, the degradation of plant-based matter is mediated by microbial consortia with complementary features which even apply “task division strategies” [69]. This global principle, together with the outcome of this work, suggest looking more into microbial consortia for superior microbial food processing. Hereby, the understanding of the needs and capabilities of the microbes involved appears crucial to deliver food via transparent and natural processes, observed benefits as the results of natural processes catalyzed by safe microbes [70,71,72,73]. In this regard, it appears interesting to test the dynamic duo of NCC 156 and NCC 1177 on other plant-based milks.

Material and methods


Strains of Propionibacterium freudenreichii (NCC 1124, NCC 1138, NCC 1145, NCC 1151, NCC 1159, NCC 1177, NCC 1186, NCC 1197, NCC 1216, NCC 1230, NCC 1236), Lacticaseibacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511, and Bacillus amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 were obtained from the Nestlé Culture Collection (NCC, Nestlé Research Centre, Lausanne, Switzerland). In addition, P. freudenreichii DSM 4902 and P. freudenreichii DSM 20,271 were obtained from the German Collection of Microorganisms and Cell Cultures (DSMZ, Braunschweig, Germany). All strains were classified as food-grade approved, based on the qualified presumption of safety (QPS) recommendation [57]. They were maintained as frozen stocks in 30% glycerol (v/v) at − 80 °C and are listed in Additional file 1: Table S1.

Strain specific pre-culture and main culture media

Depending on individual nutrient requirements, different media were used for pre-cultivation of the different strains (Additional file 1: Table S1). All strains of P. freudenreichii and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 and were grown in de Mann‐Rogosa‐Sharpe (MRS) medium, containing per litre: 52.0 g of MRS broth (Sigma-Aldrich, Steinheim, Germany) and 1.0 mL of Tween-80 (Sigma-Aldrich). In selected experiments, MRS medium was also used as main culture medium. In some of these studies, CoCl2 (50 µM) and dimethylbenzimidazole (DMBI, 100 µM) were added to the MRS medium [24, 74]. B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 was cultivated in modified tryptic soy broth (TSB) medium. It contained per litre: 17.0 g of tryptone (Becton Dickinson), 5.0 g of NaCl, 3.0 g of soytone (Becton Dickinson), 2.5 g K2HPO4, and 1.0 mL of 30% silicone antifoam (Sigma-Aldrich) [28].

Differential agar media

Lactobacillus differential (LBD) agar was used to differentiate P. freudenreichii strains from L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511. It contained per litre: 10.0 g of casein enzymatic hydrolysate (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA), 3.0 g of casein acid hydrolysate (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), 1.5 g of enzymic digest of soybean meal (Becton Dickinson), 1.0 g of yeast extract (Becton Dickinson), 2.5 g of fructose (Amresco, Solon, OH, USA), 2.5 g of K2HPO4 (Sigma-Aldrich), 55 mg of bromocresol green (Sigma-Aldrich), and 15.0 g of agar (Becton Dickinson) [75]. In addition, TSB agar was used to grow B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 for the estimation of colony forming units. It contained per litre: 17.0 g of tryptone (Becton Dickinson), 5.0 g of NaCl, 3.0 g of soytone (Becton Dickinson), 2.5 g K2HPO4, and 1.0 mL of 30% silicone antifoam, and 15.0 g of agar (Becton Dickinson) [28].

Low-pressure-pasteurized (LPP) sunflower seed milk medium

A suspension of sunflower seed press cake extract (6.8% w/w) was prepared by mixing 68 g of sunflower seed protein (All Organic Treasures) with 1 L of deionized water. The suspension was pasteurized at 90 °C for 6 h, while the temperature was monitored. Then, the milk was aseptically filled into sterile plastic bottles (2 L) and kept at 4 °C until use. Prior to cultivation, the LSP sunflower seed milk was manually homogenized. In selected supplementation studies, the pasteurized and homogenized sunflower seed milk was supplemented with one or several of the following additives: (i) CoCl2 (50 µM), riboflavin (40 µM), nicotinamide (27 mM), DMBI (100 µM), l-glutamate (0.6 mM), l-threonine (0.1 mM), glycine (0.3 mM), succinate (0.5 mM), lactate (1% w/w), and/or glucose (1% w/w). These were added from filter-sterilized stocks to final concentrations given above. Non-inoculated controls were incubated under the same conditions and evaluated for sterility by plating on TSB and LPD agar.

Ultra-high-temperature (UHT) sunflower seed milk medium

A 6.8% (w/w) sunflower seed protein suspension was prepared by mixing 68 g sunflower seed protein (All Organic Treasures) with 1 L of deionized water. The suspension was homogenized and pre-heated to 75 °C, immediately followed by continuous ultra-high temperature (UHT) treatment in an automatized pilot-scale tubular heat exchanger (HT320 (ID920), OMVE, De Meern, The Netherlands). Hereby, the pre-warmed suspension was heated for 4 s to 143 °C at a flow rate of 30 L h−1 and then efficiently cooled down to 4 °C. All sterilization parameters were controlled by the integrated process control system. Finally, the milk was aseptically filled into sterile plastic bottles (2 L) and kept at 4 °C until use. Prior to fermentation, the UHT sunflower seed milk was manually homogenized. Non-inoculated controls were incubated under the same conditions and evaluated for sterility by plating on TSB and LPD agar.


Strain specific settings (medium, temperature, and oxygen supply) were used to propagate pre-cultures (Additional file 1: Table S1) [28]. P. freudenreichii strains were grown anaerobically at 30 °C in 20 mL tubes, containing 10 mL MRS medium. For the first pre-cultivation, the tubes were inoculated from a glycerol stock (200 µL) and were then incubated overnight under a CO2 enriched atmosphere (9–13%) (Anaerobic atmosphere generation bags, Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). The first pre-culture of L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 was grown at 30 °C in 20 mL tubes, containing 10 mL MRS medium. For cultivation, the tubes were inoculated from a glycerol stock (200 µL), closed, and then incubated overnight, mimicking microaerobic conditions. B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 was grown aerobically. For this purpose, the microbe was cultivated overnight in 100 mL non-baffled shake flasks, filled with 10 mL modified TSB medium, inoculated from a glycerol stock (200 µL), and incubated on a rotary shaker (30° C, 130 rpm, 80% humidity, Infors, Bottmingen, Switzerland). Independent of the strain, cells from first pre-cultures were collected by centrifugation (5000 × g, 5 min, 4 °C) and used as inoculum for a second pre-culture, which was then grown overnight under the same conditions, then served as inoculum for the main culture. Seven selected strains were analysed for the correlation between optical density and colony forming units (cfu) during pre-cultivation. This yielded the following correlation factors f = cfu (OD600−1) during the exponential growth phase: 8.2E8 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 1177), 5.3E8 cfu (OD600−1) (DSM 4902), 8.2E8 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 1197), 1.9 E8 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 1186), 3.8E8 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 1138), 2.0E8 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 2511), and 3.6 E7 cfu (OD600−1) (NCC 156). These factors were used to infer the required amount of pre-culture needed to prepare an inoculum of desired size (see below).

Screening for vitamin B12 production

Strains of P. freudenreichii were grown in basic MRS medium and in supplemented MRS medium, additionally containing CoCl2 (50 µM) and DMBI (100 µM). Dual phase processes were conducted. Cultivation included a first anaerobic phase in 100 mL glass bottles (filled with 40 mL medium) which were inoculated from glycerol stocks and then incubated for 48 h in anaerobic jars under CO2 (9–13%). Afterwards, the broth was transferred to 100 mL baffled shake flasks and incubated aerobically for further 24 h on a rotary shaker (130 rpm, 80% humidity, 5 cm shaking diameter, Infors, Bottmingen, Switzerland). Three biological replicates were carried out for each condition.

Sunflower seed milk processing

Prior to the process, the sunflower seed milk medium was manually homogenized. While cultivations were generally conducted at 30 °C in 6.8% sunflower seed milk, other conditions were varied for optimization and testing, as described above. Anaerobic incubations were done in 100 mL glass bottles, filled with 40 mL medium and incubated in anaerobic jars under CO2 (9–13%). Aerobic incubations were conducted in in 100 mL non-baffled shake flasks, filled with 40 mL medium and incubated on a rotary shaker (80% humidity, 5 cm shaking diameter, Infors, Bottmingen, Switzerland). The shaking rate was usually set to 130 rpm but changed in selected experiments as given above. Finally, dual phase setups were conducted. After a first anaerobic bottled phase in the jar system, the broth was transferred to a shake flask for a second aerobic phase. The incubation time was varied as given below. The processes were inoculated as follows. The optical density of the corresponding pre-culture was measured. The obtained correlation between optical density and cfu (see above) was then used to calculate the pre-culture volume that contained the desired colony forming units for inoculation. This volume was collected, followed by washing of the cells with water. Then, cells in the suspension were counted using a Neubauer counting chamber. On basis of the estimated cell concentration, an appropriate volume was then used as inoculum. The initial cell concentration was adjusted to 107 cells mL−1, unless stated otherwise. In addition to monocultures, co-cultures were co-inoculated from individual pre-cultures in the same manner. Here, cells were added at different ratios, ranging from 1:1 to 1000:1, as given below. The corresponding conditions for each experiment are specified in the results section. Three biological replicates were carried out for each experiment. To minimize the impact of periodical sampling on culture conditions during time-resolved investigations, three complete incubations were sacrificed per data point, and evaporation of culture volume was considered for data correction, as previously described [72].

Quantification of cell concentration

The cell concentration (OD600) was determined as optical density at 600 nm (UV-1600PC spectrophotometer, VWR, Hannover, Germany).

Quantification of colony-forming units

Colony forming units (cfu) were determined by the plate serial dilution spotting method [28]. Briefly, 1 mL culture samples were sequentially diluted using 0.85% NaCl (w/v), supplemented with 1.0 g L−1 of tryptone (Becton Dickinson). For cfu estimation of B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, samples were spotted onto TSB agar. For cfu determination of P. freudenreichii and L. paracasei LPD agar was used. On this agar, the strain specific shape and colour of colonies formed allowed for a clear differentiation (Additional file 1: Fig. S1). All measurements were conducted in duplicate.

Quantification of sugars, organic acids, and alcohols

Sugars were quantified by HPLC (Agilent 1260 Infinity Series, Agilent Technologies, Waldbronn, Germany), involving separation on a sulfonated spherical PS/DVB resin (VA 300/7.8 Nucleogel sugar Pb, Macherey–Nagel, Düren, Germany) and refractive index detection. Deionized water served as mobile phase at 80 °C and a flow rate of 0.4 mL min−1. Organic acids and alcohols were analysed by HPLC (Agilent 1260 Infinity Series, Agilent Technologies) using an ion-exchange column (Aminex HPX-87H, Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA) as solid phase, 12 mM H2SO4 (0.5 mL min−1, 45 °C) as mobile phase, and refractive index detection (Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan). External standards were used for quantification.

Quantification of vitamin B12

The analysis of vitamin B12 was based on the method proposed by AOAC International [76] which was slightly modified in this study [77]. Briefly, 3 mL sample was mixed with 2.5 mL sodium acetate solution (0.4 M, pH 4.0) and 100 µL cyanide solution (1% w/v in deionized water), and 4.4 mL deionized water. For vitamin B12 extraction, the mixture was incubated for 20 min at 107 °C. Solids were then removed by centrifugation (5000 × g, 30 min). A defined fraction of the obtained supernatant (3 mL) was subjected to an automated immunoaffinity clean-up (GX-271 ASPEC system, Gilson, Germany). The obtained eluate from the clean-up was evaporated to dryness and dissolved in 0.3 mL ultra-pure water (> 18.2 MΩ cm−1). Subsequently, vitamin B12 was quantified using HPLC (Waters Acquity UPLC, Waters, Milford, MA, US) with separation on a silica bonded column (Acquity UPLC® HSS T3, 1.8 µm, 100 × 2.1 mm, Waters) using a gradient of water and acetonitrile as mobile phase and UV detection (550 nm). External standards were used for quantification. Levels of vitamin B12 were given as (μg cyanocobalamin) 100 g−1.

Thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, pyridoxine, and biotin analysis

Samples were hydrolysed in hydrochloric acid (100 °C, 35 min), neutralized, and filtered (0.22 µm, Millipore). The subsequent analysis was based on method LI-00.610 [78] using UHPLC-MS/MS with positive electrospray ionization and quantification via the peak area ratio of each analyte and an internal standard (Nestle Quality Assurance Center, Dublin, Republic of Ireland).

Quantification of free amino acids

For the quantification of free amino acids, 1 mL sample was centrifuged (20,000 × g, 10 min, 4 °C). The obtained supernatant was filtered (0.22 µm, Millipore) and quantified by HPLC (Agilent 1100 Infinity, Agilent Technologies) including pre-column derivatization with ortho-phthaldialdehyde and α-aminobutyric acid as internal standard [79].

Quantification of cobalt

The level of cobalt was quantified after sample work up by a high pressure asher (HPA-S High Pressure Asher, Anton Paar, IGZ Instruments, Zurich, Switzerland) using ICP-MS [78, 80].

Estimation of sunflower seed milk protein digestibility and score

The nutritional quality of sunflower seed protein from non-fermented and fermented milk was assessed on the level of different parameters: in vitro protein digestibility (IVPD), amino acid score (AAS), and in vitro protein digestibility corrected amino acid score (PDCAAS) [81]. In short, IVPD, AAS, and PDCAAS were determined using the K-PDCAAS kit (Megazyme International, Bray, Co. Wicklow, Ireland), following the instructions of the manufacturer. Briefly, samples were sequentially digested by (i) pepsin under acidic conditions, (0.06 M HCl, pH 2), and (ii) trypsin/chymotrypsin under neutral conditions (1.0 M Tris, pH 7.4) to simulate the physiological conditions of gastric and intestinal digestion. Undigested protein was precipitated by the addition of trichloroacetic acid (40% w/v) and was then removed by centrifugation (15,000 × g, 10 min). The amount of reactive α-amino acids obtained after the treatment, was quantified after derivatization with ninhydrin into a purple dye via absorbance measurement at 570 nm. From the data, the IVPD was determined by correcting for the relative reactivity of certain α -amino acids (l-proline, l-lysine, l-histidine, l-arginine). The AAS was inferred from the ratio between the amino acid amount in the sample and the amount recommended by the FAO [31]. Finally, the PDCAAS was calculated by multiplying AAS and IVPD.

GC–MS analysis of volatile flavor compounds

For the analysis of volatiles, headspace solid-phase micro-extraction (HS-SPME) (PAL RSI 120 autosampler, CTC Analytics, Switzerland) was coupled to GC–MS analysis (Agilent 8890 GC system, Agilent Technologies) [28]. Approximately 5 mL sample was immediately processed after collection. First, it was filled into a vial, supplemented with 1 g NaCl, and incubated for 20 min at 40 °C, and 400 rpm). Afterwards, an SPME fibre (65 µm, divinylbenzene/polydimethylsiloxane, preconditioned for 1 h at 260 °C, Agilent Technologies) was exposed to the headspace of the vial for 20 min to absorb the volatiles. Then, the fibre was placed into the GC–MS injector (300 °C, 3 min) for desorption [28]. The volatiles were then separated on an HP-5MS column (30 m, 0.250 mm, 0.25 µm, Agilent Technologies), using helium as carrier gas (0.4 mL min−1). Chromatograms were recorded by monitoring the total ion current (TIC) over a mass range from 30 to 300 m/z. Following deconvolution of the obtained signals (Agilent Chemstation, Agilent Technologies), individual analytes were identified through mass spectra library search (NIST/EPA/NIH Mass Spectral Library 08). The corresponding area counts for each compound were collected for quantification. Measurements were conducted in triplicate.

Data processing and statistical analysis

All results displayed in Figures and Tables are shown as mean values ± standard deviation (SD). Statistical evaluation of the data was conducted by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Differences in values were considered significant when the P value was less than 0.05 ( +) and 0.01 (+ +). Statistical analyses were performed by using SPSS (version 24.0).

Availability of data and materials

The dataset(s) supporting the conclusions of this article are all included within the article.


  1. Rauf S, Ortiz R, Shehzad M, Haider W, Ahmed I. The exploitation of sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) seed and other parts for human nutrition, medicine and the industry. Helia. 2020;43:167–84.

    Google Scholar 

  2. Tangyu M, Muller J, Bolten CJ, Wittmann C. Fermentation of plant-based milk alternatives for improved flavour and nutritional value. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. 2019;103:9263–75.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  3. Alagawany M, Farag MR, Abd El-Hack ME, Dhama K. The practical application of sunflower meal in poultry nutrition. Adv Anim Vet Sci. 2015;3:634–48.

    Google Scholar 

  4. Villamide M, San JL. Effect of chemical composition of sunflower seed meal on its true metabolizable energy and amino acid digestibility. Poult Sci. 1998;77:1884–92.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  5. Škrbić B, Filipčev B. Nutritional and sensory evaluation of wheat breads supplemented with oleic-rich sunflower seed. Food Chem. 2008;108:119–29.

    Google Scholar 

  6. de Oliveira Filho JG, Egea MB. Sunflower seed byproduct and its fractions for food application: an attempt to improve the sustainability of the oil process. J Food Sci. 2021;86:1497–510.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  7. Taha FS, Mohamed SS, El-Nockrashy AS. The use of soya bean, sunflower and lupin seeds in the preparation of protein bases for nutritious beverages. J Sci Food Agric. 1986;37:1209–16.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  8. Fleming S, Sosulski F. The utilization of sunflower protein in milk-like beverages. Can Inst Food Technol J. 1977;10:229–32.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  9. Sethi S, Tyagi SK, Anurag RK. Plant-based milk alternatives an emerging segment of functional beverages: a review. J Food Sci Technol. 2016;53:3408–23.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  10. Warren MJ, Raux E, Schubert HL, Escalante-Semerena JC. The biosynthesis of adenosylcobalamin (vitamin B12). Nat Prod Rep. 2002;19:390–412.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  11. Martin K. Interrelations between essential metal ions and human diseases. New York City: Springer; 2013.

    Google Scholar 

  12. Stabler SP. Vitamin B12 deficiency. N Engl J Med. 2013;368:149–60.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  13. Survase SA, Bajaj IB, Singhal RS. Biotechnological production of vitamins. Food Technol Biotechnol. 2006;44:381–96.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  14. Roth JR, Lawrence J, Bobik T. Cobalamin (coenzyme B12): synthesis and biological significance. Annu Rev Microbiol. 1996;50:137–81.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  15. Hörig JA, Renz P. Biosynthesis of vitamin B12: some properties of the 5, 6-dimethylbenzimidazole—forming system of Propionibacterium freudenreichii and Propionibacterium shermanii. Eur J Biochem. 1980;105:587–92.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  16. Flodin NW. The metabolic roles, pharmacology, and toxicology of lysine. J Am Coll Nutr. 1997;16:7–21.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  17. Onyesom I, Enaholo A, Mordi J. Effect of processing techniques on the contents of flatulence factors and emulsion properties of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata). J Appl Sci Environ Manage. 2005;9:65–72.

    Google Scholar 

  18. Bao X, Ma S, Fu Y, Wu J, Zhang M. Sensory and structural characterization of umami peptides derived from sunflower seed. CYTA J Food. 2020;18:485–92.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  19. Heenan SP, Dufour J-P, Hamid N, Harvey W, Delahunty CM. The sensory quality of fresh bread: descriptive attributes and consumer perceptions. Food Res Int. 2008;41:989–97.

    Google Scholar 

  20. Allen LH, Rosenberg IH, Oakley GP, Omenn GS. Considering the case for vitamin B12 fortification of flour. Food Nutr Bull. 2010;31:S36–46.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  21. Watanabe F, Yabuta Y, Bito T, Teng F. Vitamin B12-containing plant food sources for vegetarians. Nutrients. 2014;6:1861–73.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  22. Chamlagain B, Deptula P, Edelmann M, Kariluoto S, Grattepanche F, Lacroix C, Varmanen P, Piironen V. Effect of the lower ligand precursors on vitamin B12 production by food-grade Propionibacteria. LWT. 2016;72:117–24.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  23. Assis DA, Matte C, Aschidamini B, Rodrigues E, ZachiaAyub MA. Biosynthesis of vitamin B12 by Propionibacterium freudenreichii subsp. shermanii ATCC 13673 using liquid acid protein residue of soybean as culture medium. Biotechnol Prog. 2020;36: e3011.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  24. Xie C, Coda R, Chamlagain B, Varmanen P, Piironen V, Katina K. Co-fermentation of Propionibacterium freudenreichii and Lactobacillus brevis in wheat bran for in situ production of vitamin B12. Front Microbiol. 2019;10:1541.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  25. Hugenschmidt S, Schwenninger SM, Gnehm N, Lacroix C. Screening of a natural biodiversity of lactic and propionic acid bacteria for folate and vitamin B12 production in supplemented whey permeate. Int Dairy. 2010;20:852–7.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  26. Hedayati R, Hosseini M, Najafpour GD. Optimization of semi-anaerobic vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin) production from rice bran oil using Propionibacterium freudenreichii PTCC1674. Biocatal Agric Biotechnol. 2020;23: 101444.

    Google Scholar 

  27. Hugenschmidt S, Schwenninger SM, Lacroix C. Concurrent high production of natural folate and vitamin B12 using a co-culture process with Lactobacillus plantarum SM39 and Propionibacterium freudenreichii DF13. Process Biochem. 2011;46:1063–70.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  28. Tangyu M, Fritz M, Aragao-Börner R, Ye L, Bogicevic B, Bolten CJ, Wittmann C. Genome-based selection and application of food-grade microbes for chickpea milk fermentation towards increased L-lysine content, elimination of indigestible sugars, and improved flavour. Microb Cell Factor. 2021;20:1–21.

    Google Scholar 

  29. Thierry A, Deutsch S-M, Falentin H, Dalmasso M, Cousin FJ, Jan G. New insights into physiology and metabolism of Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Int J Food Microbiol. 2011;149:19–27.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  30. Ye K, Shijo M, Miyano K, Shimizu K. Metabolic pathway of Propionibacterium growing with oxygen: enzymes, 13C NMR analysis, and its application for vitamin B12 production with periodic fermentation. Biotechnol Prog. 1999;15:201–7.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  31. Food and Agriculture Organization; World Health Organization. Dietary protein quality evaluation in human nutrition: Report of an FAO Expert Consultation, FAO: Auckland; 2011.

  32. Munekata PE, Domínguez R, Budaraju S, Roselló-Soto E, Barba FJ, Mallikarjunan K, Roohinejad S, Lorenzo JM. Effect of innovative food processing technologies on the physicochemical and nutritional properties and quality of non-dairy plant-based beverages. Foods. 2020;9:288.

    CAS  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  33. Lee IH, Fredrickson A, Tsuchiya H. Diauxic growth of Propionibacterium shermanii. Appl Microbiol. 1974;28:831–5.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  34. Brendehaug J, Langsrud T. Amino acid metabolism in propionibacteria: resting cells experiments with four strains. J Dairy Sci. 1985;68:281–9.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  35. Gonzalez-Garcia RA, Mccubbin T, Navone L, Stowers C, Nielsen LK, Marcellin E. Microbial propionic acid production. Fermentation. 2017;3:21.

    Google Scholar 

  36. Falentin H, Deutsch S-M, Jan G, Loux V, Thierry A, Parayre S, Maillard M-B, Dherbecourt J, Cousin FJ, Jardin J. The complete genome of Propionibacterium freudenreichii CIRM-BIA1T, a hardy Actinobacterium with food and probiotic applications. PloS ONE. 2010;5: e11748.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  37. Bücher C, Burtscher J, Domig KJ. Propionic acid bacteria in the food industry: an update on essential traits and detection methods. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf. 2021;20:4299–323.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  38. Emde R, Schink B. Oxidation of glycerol, lactate, and propionate by Propionibacterium freudenreichii in a poised-potential amperometric culture system. Arch Microbiol. 1990;153:506–12.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  39. Beck S, Schink B. Acetate oxidation through a modified citric acid cycle in Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Arch Microbiol. 1995;163:182–7.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  40. Schwartz AC, Sporkenbach J. The electron transport system of the anaerobic Propionibacterium shermanii. Arch Microbiol. 1975;102:261–73.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  41. Dank A, van Mastrigt O, Boeren S, Lillevang SK, Abee T, Smid EJ. Propionibacterium freudenreichii thrives in microaerobic conditions by complete oxidation of lactate to CO2. Environ Microbiol. 2021;23:3116–29.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  42. Hobbs JK, Meier EP, Pluvinage B, Mey MA, Boraston AB. Molecular analysis of an enigmatic Streptococcus pneumoniae virulence factor: the raffinose-family oligosaccharide utilization system. J Biol Chem. 2019;294:17197–208.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  43. Chen XH, Koumoutsi A, Scholz R, Eisenreich A, Schneider K, Heinemeyer I, Morgenstern B, Voss B, Hess WR, Reva O. Comparative analysis of the complete genome sequence of the plant growth–promoting bacterium Bacillus amyloliquefaciens FZB42. Nat Biotechnol. 2007;25:1007–14.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  44. Dworkin M, Falkow S, Rosenberg E, Schleifer K-H, Stackebrandt E. The Prokaryotes. In: Dworkin M, editor. Archaea. Bacteria: Firmicutes, Actinomycetes, vol. 3. Berlin: Springer; 2006.

    Google Scholar 

  45. Turgay M, Bachmann H-P, Irmler S, von Ah U, Fröhlich-Wyder M-T, Falentin H, Deutsch S-M, Jan G, Thierry A. Bacteria, beneficial: Propionibacterium spp. and Acidipropionibacterium spp. In: McSweeney PLH, McNamara JP, editors. Encyclopedia of dairy sciences. 3rd ed. Amsterdam: Academic Press; 2022.

    Google Scholar 

  46. Shakoor H, Feehan J, Mikkelsen K, Al Dhaheri AS, Ali HI, Platat C, Ismail LC, Stojanovska L, Apostolopoulos V. Be well: a potential role for vitamin B in COVID-19. Maturitas. 2021;144:108–11.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  47. dos Santos LMJ. Can vitamin B12 be an adjuvant to COVID-19 treatment? GSC Biol Pharm Sci. 2020;11:001–5.

    Google Scholar 

  48. Tan CW, Ho LP, Kalimuddin S, Cherng BPZ, Teh YE, Thien SY, Wong HM, Tern PJW, Chandran M. A cohort study to evaluate the effect of combination vitamin D, magnesium and vitamin B12 (DMB) on progression to severe outcome in older COVID-19 patients. Nutrition. 2020;79–80:111017.

    CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  49. European Commission. Commission Directive 2008/100/EC of 28 October 2008 amending Council Directive 90/496/EEC on nutrition labelling for foodstuffs as regards recommended daily allowances, energy conversion factors and definitions. OJEU. 2008. p. 285.

  50. Jeske S, Zannini E, Arendt EK. Past, present and future: The strength of plant-based dairy substitutes based on gluten-free raw materials. Food Res Int. 2018;110:42–51.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  51. Ngalimat MS, Yahaya RSR, Baharudin MMA-a, Yaminudin SM, Karim M, Ahmad SA, Sabri S,. A review on the biotechnological applications of the operational group Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. Microorganisms. 2021;9:614.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  52. Chamlagain B, Sugito TA, Deptula P, Edelmann M, Kariluoto S, Varmanen P, Piironen V. In situ production of active vitamin B12 in cereal matrices using Propionibacterium freudenreichii. Food Sci Nutr. 2018;6:67–76.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  53. Xie C, Coda R, Chamlagain B, Edelmann M, Deptula P, Varmanen P, Piironen V, Katina K. In situ fortification of vitamin B12 in wheat flour and wheat bran by fermentation with Propionibacterium freudenreichii. J Cereal Sci. 2018;81:133–9.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  54. Signorini C, Carpen A, Coletto L, Borgonovo G, Galanti E, Capraro J, Magni C, Abate A, Johnson SK, Duranti M. Enhanced vitamin B12 production in an innovative lupin tempeh is due to synergic effects of Rhizopus and Propionibacterium in cofermentation. Int J Food Sci Nutr. 2018;69:451–7.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  55. Babuchowski A, Laniewska-Moroz L, Warminska-Radyko I. Propionibacteria in fermented vegetables. Lait. 1999;79:113–24.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  56. WoldemariamYohannes K, Wan Z, Yu Q, Li H, Wei X, Liu Y, Wang J, Sun B. Prebiotic, probiotic, antimicrobial, and functional food applications of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. J Agric Food Chem. 2020;68:14709–27.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  57. Ricci A, Allende A, Bolton D, Chemaly M, Davies R, Girones R, Herman L, Koutsoumanis K, Lindqvist R, Nørrung B. Scientific opinion on the update of the list of QPS-recommended biological agents intentionally added to food or feed as notified to EFSA. EFSA J. 2017;15(3):e04663.

    CAS  Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  58. Fang H, Kang J, Zhang D. Microbial production of vitamin B12: a review and future perspectives. Microb Cell Factor. 2017;16:1–14.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  59. Lingens B, Schild TA, Vogler B, Renz P. Biosynthesis of vitamin B12: Transformation of riboflavin 2H-labeled in the 1′R position or 1′S position into 5, 6-dimethylbenzimidazole. Eur J Biochem. 1992;207:981–5.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  60. Lichstein HC. The biotin requirements of the genus Propionibacterium. Arch Biochem Biophys. 1955;58:423–30.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  61. Furuichi K, Hojo K-i, Katakura Y, Ninomiya K, Shioya S. Aerobic culture of Propionibacterium freudenreichii ET-3 can increase production ratio of 1, 4-dihydroxy-2-naphthoic acid to menaquinone. J Biosci Bioeng. 2006;101:464–70.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  62. Sieuwerts S, De Bok FA, Hugenholtz J, van Hylckama Vlieg JE. Unraveling microbial interactions in food fermentations: from classical to genomics approaches. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2008;74:4997–5007.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  63. Ciani M, Comitini F. Yeast interactions in multi-starter wine fermentation. Curr Opin Food Sci. 2015;1:1–6.

    Google Scholar 

  64. Adler P, Frey LJ, Berger A, Bolten CJ, Hansen CE, Wittmann C. The key to acetate: metabolic fluxes of acetic acid bacteria under cocoa pulp fermentation-simulating conditions. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2014;80:4702–16.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  65. Krusong W, Yongsmith B, Sanchez PC. Influence of Lactobacillus casei in production of high vitamin B12-tempeh. Agric Nat Resour. 1991;25:458–62.

    Google Scholar 

  66. Van Wyk J, Witthuhn RC, Britz TJ. Optimisation of vitamin B12 and folate production by Propionibacterium freudenreichii strains in kefir. Int Dairy J. 2011;21:69–74.

    Google Scholar 

  67. Xie C, Coda R, Chamlagain B, Edelmann M, Varmanen P, Piironen V, Katina K. Fermentation of cereal, pseudo-cereal and legume materials with Propionibacterium freudenreichii and Levilactobacillus brevis for vitamin B12 fortification. LWT. 2021;137: 110431.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  68. Petraru A, Ursachi F, Amariei S. Nutritional characteristics assessment of sunflower seeds, oil and cake. Perspective of using sunflower oilcakes as a functional ingredient. Plants. 2021;10:2487.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  69. Weiland F, Kohlstedt M, Wittmann C. Guiding stars to the field of dreams: Metabolically engineered pathways and microbial platforms for a sustainable lignin-based industry. Metab Eng. 2021.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  70. Schwechheimer SK, Becker J, Wittmann C. Towards better understanding of industrial cell factories: novel approaches for 13C metabolic flux analysis in complex nutrient environments. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 2018;54:128–37.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  71. Schwechheimer SK, Becker J, Peyriga L, Portais J-C, Sauer D, Müller R, Hoff B, Haefner S, Schröder H, Zelder O. Improved riboflavin production with Ashbya gossypii from vegetable oil based on 13C metabolic network analysis with combined labeling analysis by GC/MS, LC/MS, 1D, and 2D NMR. Metab Eng. 2018;47:357–73.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  72. Schwechheimer SK, Becker J, Peyriga L, Portais J-C, Wittmann C. Metabolic flux analysis in Ashbya gossypii using 13C-labeled yeast extract: industrial riboflavin production under complex nutrient conditions. Microb Cell Fact. 2018;17:162.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  73. Kohlstedt M, Sappa PK, Meyer H, Maaß S, Zaprasis A, Hoffmann T, Becker J, Steil L, Hecker M, van Dijl JM. Adaptation of Bacillus subtilis carbon core metabolism to simultaneous nutrient limitation and osmotic challenge: a multi-omics perspective. Environ Microbiol. 2014;16:1898–917.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  74. Moore SJ, Mayer MJ, Biedendieck R, Deery E, Warren MJ. Towards a cell factory for vitamin B12 production in Bacillus megaterium: bypassing of the cobalamin riboswitch control elements. N Biotechnol. 2014;31:553–61.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  75. Adler P, Bolten CJ, Dohnt K, Hansen CE, Wittmann C. Core fluxome and metafluxome of lactic acid bacteria under simulated cocoa pulp fermentation conditions. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2013;79:5670–81.

    CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  76. Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC INTERNATIONAL (2019). In Method 201402, 21st edition. Rockville, MD, USA: AOAC International; 2019.

  77. Giménez EC, Martin F. Vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin) in infant formula adult/pediatric nutritional formula by liquid chromatography with ultraviolet detection: collaborative study, final action 2014.02. J AOAC Int. 2018;101:1112–8.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  78. Dubascoux S, Payot JR, Sylvain P, Nicolas M, Gimenez EC. Vitamin B12 quantification in human milk–Beyond current limitations using liquid chromatography and inductively coupled plasma–Mass spectrometry. Food Chem. 2021;362: 130197.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  79. Wittmann C. Fluxome analysis using GC-MS. Microb Cell Fact. 2007;6:6.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  80. Hammer D, Nicolas M, Andrey D. Improved chromium determination in various food matrices using dynamic reaction cell ICP-MS. At Spectrosc. 2005;26:203–8.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  81. Schaafsma G. The protein digestibility–corrected amino acid score. J Nutr. 2000;130:1865S-1867S.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  82. Boatright W, Lei Q. Compounds contributing to the “beany” odor of aqueous solutions of soy protein isolates. J Food Sci. 1999;64:667–70.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  83. The Good Scents Company Information System. The Good Scents Company. 2021. Accessed 15 Feb 2022.

  84. Xu M, Jin Z, Lan Y, Rao J, Chen B. HS-SPME-GC-MS/olfactometry combined with chemometrics to assess the impact of germination on flavor attributes of chickpea, lentil, and yellow pea flours. Food Chem. 2019;280:83–95.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  85. Verginer M, Leitner E, Berg G. Production of volatile metabolites by grape-associated microorganisms. J Agric Food Chem. 2010;58:8344–50.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  86. Sabatini N, Mucciarella MR, Marsilio V. Volatile compounds in uninoculated and inoculated table olives with Lactobacillus plantarum (Olea europaea L., cv. Moresca and Kalamata). LWT. 2008;41:2017–22.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  87. Lv Y-C, Song H-L, Li X, Wu L, Guo S-T. Influence of blanching and grinding process with hot water on beany and non-beany flavor in soymilk. J Food Sci. 2011;76:S20–5.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  88. Yang DS, Shewfelt RL, Lee K-S, Kays SJ. Comparison of odor-active compounds from six distinctly different rice flavor types. J Agric Food Chem. 2008;56:2780–7.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  89. Fu M, Shen X, Peng H, Zhou Q, Yun J, Sun Y, Ho C-T, Cai H, Hou R. Identification of rancidity markers in roasted sunflower seeds produced from raw materials stored for different periods of time. LWT. 2020;118: 108721.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  90. Ounamornas P, Page P, Sommano S: Aromatic profile changes of Thai mangoes during heat processing. In: XII International Mango Symposium 1244. 2017: 181–6.

  91. Högnadóttir Á, Rouseff RL. Identification of aroma active compounds in orange essence oil using gas chromatography–olfactometry and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. J Chromatogr A. 2003;998:201–11.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  92. Xiao Z, Li Q, Niu Y, Zhou X, Liu J, Xu Y, Xu Z. Odor-active compounds of different lavender essential oils and their correlation with sensory attributes. Ind Crops Prod. 2017;108:748–55.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  93. Aznar M, López R, Cacho JF, Ferreira V. Identification and quantification of impact odorants of aged red wines from Rioja. GC−Olfactometry, quantitative GC-MS, and odor evaluation of HPLC fractions. J Agric Food Chem. 2001;49:2924–9.

    CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  94. Zeng Z, Zhang H, Chen JY, Zhang T, Matsunaga R. Flavor volatiles of rice during cooking analyzed by modified headspace SPME/GC-MS. Cereal Chem. 2008;85:140–5.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  95. Van Opstaele F, Causmaecker BD, Aerts G, Cooman LD. Characterization of novel varietal floral hop aromas by headspace solid phase microextraction and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry/olfactometry. J Agric Food Chem. 2012;60:12270–81.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  96. Costa R, Zellner BdA, Crupi ML, Fina MRD, Valentino MR, Dugo P, Dugo G, Mondello L. GC–MS, GC–O and enantio–GC investigation of the essential oil of Tarchonanthus camphoratus L. Flavour Fragr J. 2008;23:40–8.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  97. Giri A, Osako K, Okamoto A, Ohshima T. Olfactometric characterization of aroma active compounds in fermented fish paste in comparison with fish sauce, fermented soy paste and sauce products. Food Res Int. 2010;43:1027–40.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

Download references


This work is dedicated to the memory of Dr. Judith Becker (2.2. 1981 – 27.4.2021), our close and cherished colleague at the Institute of Systems Biotechnology, Saarland University, and our true friend.


Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. This study was funded by Nestec Ltd. (Vevey, Switzerland), which has been merged with Société des Produits Nestlé SA on 1st of June 2019.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations



MT, CW, LY, BB, RAB and CJB selected the strains. LY and BB conducted the initial screening of the propionibacteria. MT performed all other cultivation studies and analyzed cell growth, sugars, organic acids, amino acids, and flavor profiles. MF supported flavor analysis. DMB and ECG analyzed vitamins and cobalt. CW conceived and structured the work. M.T. and C.W. wrote the first draft of the manuscript. MT and CW prepared all figures. All authors critically commented, improved, and approved the final manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Christoph Wittmann.

Ethics declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable. The manuscript does not contain data collected from humans or animals.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

Christoph Joseph Bolten, Rosa Aragão Börner, Liyuan Ye, Esther Campos-Giménez, Delphine Morin-Rivron and Biljana Bogicevic are employed by Nestlé Research, Switzerland, which is part of Société des Produits Nestlé SA, a wholly owned subsidiary of Nestlé SA. Nestec Ltd. (Vevey, Switzerland) has filed patent applications related to this study, involving Muzi Tangyu and Christoph Wittmann as inventors. Michel Fritz declares that he has no competing interests.

Additional information

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Supplementary Information

Additional file 1: Figure S1.

Colony morphology used to assess strain-specific colony forming units in co-cultures. P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 on LPD agar (A); B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 on TSB agar; L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 on LPD agar (C). Figure S2. Time resolved changes of dissolved oxygen and pH value during aerobic growth on sunflower seed milk. The data comprise cultures using P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 (A), L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 (B), B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 (C), and a co-culture of two strains (D). n=1. Figure S3. Co-cultivation of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 in UHT-processed sunflower seed milk. The data comprise colony forming units (A), the content of vitamin B12 (B), and vitamins B3, B6, and B7 (C), the relative amount of favored and unfavored volatile, inferred from the total peak area of GC/MS-based volatile analysis (D), the level sucrose, raffinose, and stachyose (E), the level of extracellular l-lysine, l-leucine, l-tryptophan, and l-methionine (F), the level of acetoin, 2,3-butanediol, propionate, and acetate (G), and the protein score PDCAAS (H). n=3. Table S1. Strain specific pre-culture conditions. As media, Mann-Rogosa-Sharpe medium (MRS) and modified tryptic soy broth (TSB) were used. Regarding oxygen supply, strains of P. freudenreichii were grown under anaerobic conditions. L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 was grown under microaerobic conditions, and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 was grown aerobically. All strains were grown at 30 °C. Table S2A. Growth and vitamin B12 production of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 on sunflower seed milk: Impact of different supplements added to the process. The incubation in the supplemented plant milk was carried out at 30 °C for 72 hours, including an initial anaerobic phase (48 hours), followed by an aerobic phase (24 hours). In addition, a non-supplemented process was conducted as control. The plant milk was pasteurized prior to cultivation. The vitamin B12 level and the cfu number reflect the final values at the end of the fermentation. n=3. Table S3. Metabolic profile of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177, B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156, and L. paracasei subsp. paracasei NCC 2511 after aerobic and anaerobic growth on pasteurized sunflower seed milk. The fermentation was carried out at 30 °C either anaerobically (48 hours) or aerobically (24 hours). In addition, the composition of the milk at the start (including the inoculum) is given. For each parameter, the maximum absolute concentration change (increase or decrease), observed among all conditions, is highlighted in yellow. For the representation of the data as relative changes, this maximum change was normalized to a value of 1. The change of the other conditions was normalized to this maximum (Fig. 3). The data represent the final values under each condition. n=3. Table S4. Growth and vitamin B12 production during co-culturing of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 in pasteurized sunflower seed milk: Impact of inoculum level and process conditions. In different set-ups, strain NCC 1177 was inoculated at a 10-fold, 100-fold, and 1,000-fold higher level than strain NCC 156. In all cases, the total inoculum of both strains was 2 × 107 cfu mL-1. Regarding process operation, one set-up comprised first a 24 h aerobic phase, followed by a 48-h anaerobic phase, whereas the two phases were reverted in a second set-up. All fermentations were carried out at 30 °C. The plant milk was pasteurized prior to fermentation. Vitamin level and cell growth display the final values after 72 h. n=3. Table S5. Dynamics of free amino acids during co-culturing of P. freudenreichii NCC 1177 and B. amyloliquefaciens NCC 156 in UHT-treated sunflower seed milk. The process involved a 48-h anaerobic phase, followed by a 48-h aerobic phase. n=3.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver ( applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Tangyu, M., Fritz, M., Ye, L. et al. Co-cultures of Propionibacterium freudenreichii and Bacillus amyloliquefaciens cooperatively upgrade sunflower seed milk to high levels of vitamin B12 and multiple co-benefits. Microb Cell Fact 21, 48 (2022).

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI:


  • Sunflower seed milk
  • Co-culture
  • Microbial consortium
  • Vitamin B2
  • Vitamin B3
  • Vitamin B7, vitamin B12, l-lysine
  • Flavor
  • Indigestible sugar
  • Propionibacterium freudenreichii NCC 1177
  • Bacillus amyloliquefaciens NCC 156