Mucosal vaccine delivery by non-recombinant spores of Bacillus subtilis
© Ricca et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2014
Received: 17 June 2014
Accepted: 31 July 2014
Published: 12 August 2014
Development of mucosal vaccines strongly relies on an efficient delivery system and, over the years, a variety of approaches based on phages, bacteria or synthetic nanoparticles have been proposed to display and deliver antigens. The spore of Bacillus subtilis displaying heterologous antigens has also been considered as a mucosal vaccine vehicle, and shown able to conjugate some advantages of live microrganisms with some of synthetic nanoparticles. Here we review the use of non-recombinant spores of B. subtilis as a delivery system for mucosal immunizations. The non-recombinant display is based on the adsorption of heterologous molecules on the spore surface without the need of genetic manipulations, thus avoiding all concerns about the use and environmental release of genetically modified microorganisms. In addition, adsorbed molecules are stabilized and protected by the interaction with the spore, suggesting that this system could reduce the rapid degradation of the antigen, often observed with other delivery systems and identified as a major drawback of mucosal vaccines.
KeywordsVaccine vehicles Vaccine delivery Drug delivery Surface display
Currently licensed vaccines are delivered by one of five main administration routes. The intramuscular route is the most common one and several vaccines, such as hepatitis A and B, rabies, influenza, diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis, are delivered by this approach. Subcutaneous and intradermal routes are also common and used, for example, for measles-mumps-rubella-yellow fever and BCG-rabies vaccinations, respectively. The remaining two routes deliver antigens to the nasal or intestinal mucosal surfaces. The intranasal route is used, for example, for live attenuated influenza viruses while the oral route is used for poliomyelitis, cholera, rotavirus and typhoid fever vaccinations.
Mucosally administered vaccines have a number of potential advantages over injectable vaccines: no risk of transmission of blood-borne diseases; no need of trained personnel to administer and the possibility to elicit an immune response at the portal of entry of most pathogens . However, despite these potential advantages and early success with the oral polio vaccine more than 50 years ago, injectable vaccines are widely more common than mucosal ones . This is in part due to a number of drawbacks associated with currently available mucosal vaccines, such as poor antigen adsorption, rapid antigen degradation on the mucosal surfaces and lack of safe and effective mucosal adjuvants . Recent advances in mucosal immunology, and recent success with the development of mucosal vaccines against influenza and rotavirus infections have renewed interest in the development of a new generation of mucosal vaccines. Public health organizations are urging the scientific community to focus on the development of efficient systems to deliver antigens to mucosal sites that facilitate uptake by local antigen-presenting cells, and on the discovery of safe and effective mucosal adjuvants that enhance the protective mucosal immune response.
We review here the use of non-recombinant spores of Bacillus subtilis as a delivery system for mucosal immunizations. Spores of B. subtilis are extremely resistant and stable, easy to manipulate and are known to interact with immune cells inducing protective, antigen-specific immune responses . A variety of antigens have been displayed on the surface of recombinant B. subtilis spores and used to immunize animal models through the nasal and/or oral route . Like other display systems, also the spore-based approach rely on the genetic engineering of the host. This raises concerns over the use of live genetically modified microorganisms, their release into nature and their clearance from the host following delivery . To overcome this obstacle a non-recombinant approach to display heterologous proteins on the spore surface has been recently proposed.
The spore of Bacillus subtilis
Spores are quiescent cells mainly produced by members of two genera of Gram-positive bacteria, the aerobic or facultative anaerobic Bacilli and the anaerobic Clostridia. The common feature of these organisms is the ability to respond to harsh environmental conditions differentiating a spore from a vegetative cell. Because of its peculiar structure the spore is extremely stable and survives indefinitely to the absence of water and nutrients, to the presence of lytic enzymes and toxic chemicals, of UV irradiation and to extremes of temperature and pH . However, in the presence of water, nutrients and favourable environmental conditions, the spore germinates generating a cell able to duplicate vegetatively and, eventually, to re-sporulate. The processes of sporulation and germination in Bacillus subtilis, the model system for spore-formers, have been recently reviewed ,.
In B. subtilis the spore structure has been studied in details and shown to be formed by a dehydrated cytoplasm (core) surrounded by several protective layers: the thick peptidoglycan-like cortex, the multilayered, proteinaceous coat and the crust, the outermost layer formed of proteins and glycans . Interestingly, several spore surface proteins have the ability to self-assemble , and the entire spore can self-assemble into functional structures .
Despite their metabolic quiescence, spores are dynamic structures able to respond to changes in relative humidity by expanding and shrinking . It has been measured that in response to humidity the B. subtilis spore can change its diameter by as much as 12% ,. Such variations have been recently used for energy conversion and have proposed the spore as a building block for novel stimuli-responsive materials with potential applications in energy harvesting and storage .
Examples of commercial products containing spores of B. subtilis for human or animal use 1
Tediphar Corporation (VietNam)
Protexin Health Care (UK)
3 × 106 plus other bacteria
Ildong Pharma (Korea)
1.6 × 109 plus other bacteria
Provita Eurotech (UK)
Poultry, calves, swine
1.6 × 109 plus other bacteria
Christian Hansen (Denmark)
Microbial Solutions (South Africa)
1 × 108
Sino-Aqua Corp. (Taiwan)
3 × 106 plus other bacteria
Ildong Pharma (Korea)
2 × 109
Ist. Biochimico Italiano (Italy)
1 × 108 plus other bacteria
Hanmi Pharmaceutical (China)
Nature’s First Food
Nature’s First Law (USA)
1 × 108
Pasteur Institute (VietNam)
Garden of Life (USA)
Recombinant spore-surface display
Non-recombinant spore-surface display
In a similar way also a model enzyme, the β-galactosidase of Alicyclobacillus acidocaldaricus, was efficiently adsorbed to B. subtilis spores . Also in this case adsorption was dependent of the pH of the binding solution and was more efficient at acidic than neutral or basic conditions. This study, although not performed with an antigen, revealed some properties of spore adsorption that could turn out potentially useful for the development of new mucosal vaccines: 1) the adsorbed enzyme was more stable than the unbound, free enzyme at both high temperatures and low pH values, suggesting that the interaction with the spore stabilizes and protects the heterologous protein; 2) mutant spores with a strongly altered surface adsorbed the enzyme more efficiently than isogenic wild type spores . B. subtilis spores are known to be negatively charged and in an aqueous environment behave like almost infinite ionic reservoirs accumulating billions of protons (approximately 2 × 1010 per spore) . An expected consequence of the reduced number of free protons in solution is a pH increase and, indeed, 2 × 109 spores were able to raise the pH of pure water from 5.98 to over 7.00 . The same amounts of mutant spores with either a strongly altered (cotH) or a totally lacking (cotE) outer coat did not alter the pH of pure water, indicating that they did not attract protons and, therefore, are not (or less) negatively charged . Since these mutant spores adsorb β-Gal more efficiently than wild type spores, the negative electric charge of the spore is not a major determinant of β-Gal adsorption . More recently another enzyme, the cellobiose 2-epimerase of Caldicellulosiruptor saccharolyticus has been adsorbed on the spore surface . Also in this case, the spore-immobilized enzyme showed a higher pH and thermal stability than the free enzyme. Adsorption was very stable and the enzyme detached from the spore surface only by a drastic treatment with 1.0 M NaCl at pH 1.0 .
Live as well as heat-inactivated spores were also shown able to bind influenza H5N1 virions (NIBRG-14; clade 1) . Groups of mice intranasally immunized with killed spores adsorbed with NIBRG-14 were able to fully protect the animals in a challenge experiment with a lethal dose (20 times the LD50) of the virus. Particularly interesting is the observation that killed spores without any adsorbed virion were able to partially protect (60%) the animals through the induction of an innate immune response, suggesting for the spore an adjuvant role for H5N1 vaccination .
Spores of B. subtilis have also been used to adsorb two Mycobacterium tuberculosis antigens: i) MPT64, a 25-kDa secreted protein, not produced by attenuated strains, characterized by a highly immunogenic activity and shown able to confer partial protection in challenge experiments with a mouse models ; and ii) the chimera Acr-Ag85B, formed by two antigens, Acr preferentially recognized by latently infected individuals and Ag85B, one of the most protective antigens of M. tuberculosis. As in the previous cases, adsorption of the two M. tuberculosis antigens was pH-dependent. Intranasally administered spores were able to reach the alveoli and to induce both humoral and cellular immune responses . Immunized animals were protected in a challenge experiment and presented reduced mycobacterial loads in their lungs and spleens, confirming that mucosal vaccinations are particularly effective against pathogens entering the animal body through the mucosal surfaces .
Recombinant vs. non-recombinant spore-surface display
A recent report has compared the efficiency of recombinant and non-recombinant spore display using as a model antigen the binding subunit of the heat-labile toxin (LTB) of Escherichia coli. LTB displayed by both strategies was able to induce a specific immune response in mucosally immunized mice ,. An average of 9.6 × 10-5 pg of LTB/spore, corresponding to approx. 200 ng of LTB in a dose of 2 × 109 spores, were displayed by the recombinant approach (CotC-LTB), while the same number of spores was able to display up to 5.5 μg of LTB by the non-recombinant approach . The 25-fold higher efficiency of display obtained with the non-recombinant strategy than with the recombinant one was further improved using mutant spores with an altered outer coat (cotH mutant spores). 2 × 109 cotH spores adsorbed approx. 14 μg of LTB, about 70-fold more efficient than the antigen displayed by the recombinant approach . The increased efficiency of display of non-recombinant vs. recombinant approach is particularly relevant since it allows to reduce the number of spores needed to induce an immune response. Effective immunizations have been obtained in mice dosing the animals with at least nine doses of 1.0 × 1010 recombinant spores . Scaling up that number to immunize humans would be extremely difficult or even not realistic, making necessary to use a more efficient display systems.
Advantages of the non-recombinant spore-based delivery system
The use of B. subtilis spores, both by the recombinant and non-recombinant approach, has several advantages over other cell- or phage-based display systems. A first advantage comes from the safety of B. subtilis spores for human use. The widespread utilization of spores of this species in commercial probiotic preparations and in traditional food preparations (Table 1) represents an exceptional safety record for the B. subtilis species. Other advantages come from the well documented robustness of the spore which grants high stability to the display system even after a prolonged storage . The stability of the delivery system is an important requirement in developing new mucosal vaccine, especially if intended for vaccination programmes in developing countries, where poor distribution and storage conditions are major limitations.
To these advantages the non-recombinant display approach adds additional favourable properties. No genetic manipulation is required for the display, eliminating concerns over the use and release of recombinant microorganisms. Spore-adsorbed proteins are stabilized and protected by the interaction with the spore and are more stable that free proteins to high temperatures and acidic pH conditions , suggesting that spore-exposed antigens may have a longer half-life at mucosal surfaces.
The non-recombinant approach is more efficient than the recombinant spore display system, allowing to use up to 70-fold less spores to deliver a similar amount of antigen. Finally, only the non-recombinant approach allows the disply of multimeric antigens in their native form, in turn ensuring the recognition of the natural receptor and a proper activation of the immune system .
Future developments of the non-recombinant spore display system will necessarily have to be based on a better understanding of the mechanisms involved in spore adsorption. A combination of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions between spores and passengers have initially been suggested as responsible of the adhesion . However, in the case of β-galactosidase adsorption the role of electrostatic force has been shown to be not predominant . It is possible that adsorption is somehow multifactorial and not due to a single mechanism, however, whether other factors (e.g., van der Waals and capillary forces) are also involved, how the involved forces are affected by external factors such as humidity, or by properties of the passenger protein are all relevant questions that still need to be addressed. Relevant in this frame is the observation that spores can be studied at a single-cell level by the use of optical tweezers, thus opening to the possibility of a deep characterization of the physico-chemical properties of the spore surface .
This work was supported by EU (VII Framework, contract number 613703 and 614088 to ER).
- De Magistris MT: Mucosal delivery of vaccine antigens and its advantages in pediatrics. Adv Drug Deliv Rev. 2006, 58: 52-67. 10.1016/j.addr.2006.01.002.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Woodrow KA, Bennett KM, Lo DD: Mucosal vaccine design and delivery. Ann Rev Biomed Eng. 2012, 14: 17-46. 10.1146/annurev-bioeng-071811-150054.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cutting SM, Hong HA, Baccigalupi L, Ricca E: Oral vaccine delivery by recombinant spore probiotics. Intern Rev Immunol. 2009, 28: 487-505. 10.3109/08830180903215605.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Isticato R, Ricca E: Spore Surface Display. The Bacterial Spore. Edited by: Driks A, Eichemberger P. 2014, ASM press, Washigton DC, US, in pressGoogle Scholar
- Detmer A, Glenting J: Live bacterial vaccines—a review and identification of potential hazards. Microb Cell Fact. 2006, 5: 23-10.1186/1475-2859-5-23.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fritze D: Taxonomy and systematics of the aerobic endospore forming bacteria: Bacillus and related genera. Bacterial Spore Formers. Edited by: Ricca E, Henriques AO, Cutting SM. 2004, Horizon Biosience, Norfolk, UK, 17-34.Google Scholar
- McKenney PT, Driks A, Eichemberger P: TheBacillus subtilisendospore: assembly and functions of the multilayered coat.Nat Rev Microbiol 2013, 11:33–44.,Google Scholar
- Dworkin J, Shah IM: Exit from dormancy in microbial organisms. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2010, 8: 890-896. 10.1038/nrmicro2453.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Higgins D, Dworkin J: Recent progress inBacillus subtilissporulation.FEMS Microbiol Rev 2012, 36:131–148.,Google Scholar
- Tang J, Krajcikova D, Zhu R, Ebner A, Cutting S, Gruber HJ, Barak I, Hinterdorfer P: Atomic force microscopy imaging and single molecule recognition force spectroscopy of coat proteins on the surface ofBacillus subtilisspore.J Mol Recognit 2007, 20:483–489.,Google Scholar
- Ramamurthi KS, Losick R: ATP-driven self-assembly of a morphogenetic protein inBacillus subtilis.Mol Cell 2008, 31:406–414.,Google Scholar
- Chen X, Mahadevan L, Driks A, Sahin O: Bacillusspores as building blocks for stimuliresponsive materials and nanogenerators.Nature Nanotechnol 2014, 9:137–141.,Google Scholar
- Driks A: The dynamic spore. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2003, 100: 3007-3009. 10.1073/pnas.0730807100.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Plomp M, Leighton TJ, Wheeler KE, Malkin AJ: The high-resolution architecture and structural dynamics ofBacillusspores.Biophys J 2005, 88:603–608.,Google Scholar
- Nicholson WL: Roles ofBacillusendospores in the environment.Cell Mol Life Sci 2002, 59:410–416.,Google Scholar
- Nicholson WL: Roles ofBacillusendospores in the environment.Cell Mol Life Sci 2002, 59:410–416.,Google Scholar
- Hong HA, To E, Fakhry S, Baccigalupi L, Ricca E, Cutting SM: Defining the natural habitat ofBacillusspore-formers.Res Microbiol 2009, 160:375–379.,Google Scholar
- Fakhry S, Sorrentini I, Ricca E, De Felice M, Baccigalupi L: Characterisation of spore forming Bacilli isolated from the human gastrointestinal tract. J Appl Microbiol. 2008, 105: 2178-2186. 10.1111/j.1365-2672.2008.03934.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Casula G, Cutting SM: Bacillusprobiotics: spore germination in the gastrointestinal tract.Appl Environ Microbiol 2002, 68:2344–2352.,Google Scholar
- Cutting SM: Bacillus probiotics. Food Microbiol. 2011, 28: 214-220. 10.1016/j.fm.2010.03.007.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Duc LH, Hong AH, Nguyen QU, Cutting SM: Intracellular fate and immunogenicity of B. subtilis spores. Vaccine. 2004, 22: 1873-1885. 10.1016/j.vaccine.2003.11.021.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fujita M, Musch MW, Nakagawa Y, Hu S, Alverdy J, Kohgo Y, Schneewind O, Jabri B, Chang EB: TheBacillus subtilisquorum-sensing molecule CSF contribute to intestinal homoestasis via OCTN2, a host cell membrane transporter.Cell Host Microb 2007, 1:299–308.,Google Scholar
- Ceragioli M, Cangiano G, Esin S, Ghelardi E, Ricca E, Senesi S: Phagocytosis, germination and killing ofBacillus subtilisspores presenting heterologous antigens in human macrophages.Microbiology 2009, 155:338–346.,Google Scholar
- Rhee K-J, Sethupathi P, Driks A, Lanning DK, Knight KL: Role of commensal bacteria in development of gut-associated lymphoid tissue and preimmune antibody repertoire. J Immunol. 2004, 172: 1118-1124. 10.4049/jimmunol.172.2.1118.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- D’Arienzo R, Maurano F, Mazzarella G, Luongo D, Stefanile R, Ricca E, Rossi M: Bacillus subtilisspores reduce susceptibility toCitrobacter rodentium-mediated enteropathy in a mouse model.Res Microbiol 2006, 157:891–897.,Google Scholar
- Isticato R, Cangiano G, Tran T-H, Ciabattini A, Medaglini D, Oggioni MR, De Felice M, Pozzi G, Ricca E: Surface display of recombinant proteins onBacillus subtilisspores.J Bacteriol 2001, 183:6294–6301.,Google Scholar
- Duc LH, Huynh HA, Fairweather N, Ricca E, Cutting SM: Bacterial spores as vaccine vehicles. Infect Immun. 2003, 71: 2810-2818. 10.1128/IAI.71.5.2810-2818.2003.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mauriello EMF, Cangiano G, Maurano F, Saggese V, De Felice M, Rossi M, Ricca E: Germination-independent induction of cellular immune response byBacillus subtilisspores displaying the C fragment of the tetanus toxin.Vaccine 2007, 25:788–793.,Google Scholar
- Iwanicki A, Piątek I, Stasiłojć M, Grela A, Lęga T, Obuchowski M, Hinc K: A system of vectors forBacillus subtilisspore surface display.Microb Cell Fact 2014, 13:30.,Google Scholar
- Huang JM, Hong HA, Van Tong H, Hoang TH, Brisson A, Cutting SM: Mucosal delivery of antigens using adsorption to bacterial spores. Vaccine. 2010, 28: 1021-1030. 10.1016/j.vaccine.2009.10.127.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sirec T, Strazzulli A, Isticato R, De Felice M, Moracci M, Ricca E: Adsorption of beta-galactosidase ofAlicyclobacillus acidocaldariuson wild type and mutants spores ofBacillus subtilis.Microb Cell Fact 2012, 11:100.,Google Scholar
- Kazakov S, Bonvouloir E, Gazaryan I: Physicochemical characterization of natural ionic microreservoirs:Bacillus subtilisdormant spores.J Phys Chem 2008, 112:2233–2244.,Google Scholar
- Gu J, Yang R, Hua X, Zhang W, Zhao W: Adsorption-based immobilization ofCaldicellulosiruptor saccharolyticuscellobiose 2-epimerase onBacillus subtilisspores.Biotechnol Appl Biochem 2014. in press doi:10.1002/bab.1262.,Google Scholar
- Song M, Hong HA, Huang JM, Colenutt C, Khang DD, Nguyen TV, Park SM, Shim BS, Song HH, Cheon IS, Jang JE, Choi JA, Choi YK, Stadler K, Cutting SM: KilledBacillus subtilisspores as a mucosal adjuvant for an H5N1 vaccine.Vaccine 2012, 30:3266–3277.,Google Scholar
- Delogu G, Howard A, Collins FM, Morris SL: DNA vaccination against tuberculosis: expression of a ubiquitin-conjugated tuberculosis protein enhances antimycobacterial immunity. Infect Immun. 2000, 68: 3097-3102. 10.1128/IAI.68.6.3097-3102.2000.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Reljic R, Sibley L, Huang JM, Pepponi I, Hoppe A, Hong HA, Cutting SM: Mucosal vaccination against tuberculosis using inert bioparticles. Infect Immun. 2013, 81: 4071-4080. 10.1128/IAI.00786-13.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Isticato R, Sirec T, Treppiccione L, Maurano F, De Felice M, Rossi M, Ricca E: Non-recombinant display of the B subunit of the heat labile toxin ofEscherichia colion wild type and mutant spores ofBacillus subtilis.Microb Cell Fact 2013, 12:98.,Google Scholar
- Mauriello EMF, Duc LH, Isticato R, Cangiano G, Hong HA, De Felice M, Ricca E, Cutting SM: Display of heterologous antigens on theBacillus subtilisspore coat using cotc as a fusion partner.Vaccine 2004, 22:1177–1187.,Google Scholar
- Kim J-M, Park S-M, Kim J-A, J-a P, M-h Y, Kim N-S, Bae J-L, Park GS, Jang J-S, Yang M-S, Kim D-H: Functional pentameric formation via coexpression of theEscherichia coliheat-labile enterotoxin B subunit and its fusion protein subunit with a Neutralizing Epitope of ApxIIA Exotoxin improves the mucosal immunogenicity and protection against challenge byActinobacillus pleuropneumoniae.Clin Vaccine Immunol 2011, 18:2168–2177.,Google Scholar
- Ricci S, Medaglini D, Rush CM, Marcello A, Peppoloni S, Manganelli R, Palú G, Pozzi G: Immunogenicity of the B monomer ofEscherichia coliheat labile toxin expressed on the surface ofStreptococcus gordonii.Infect Immun 2000, 68:760–766.,Google Scholar
- Nashar TO, Webb HM, Eaglestone S, Williams NA, Hirst TR: Potent immunogenicity of the B subunits ofEscherichia coliheat-labile enterotoxin: receptor binding is essential and induces differential modulation of lymphocyte subsets.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1996, 93:226–230.,Google Scholar
- Nashar TO, Betteridge ZE, Mitchell RN: Evidence for a role of ganglioside GM1 in antigen presentation: binding enhances presentation ofEscherichia colienterotoxin B subunit (EtxB) to CD4(+) T cells.Int Immunol 2001, 13:541–551.,Google Scholar
- Isticato R, Cangiano G, De Felice M, Ricca E: Display of Molecules on the Spore Surface. Bacterial Spore Formers. Edited by: Ricca E, Henriques AO, Cutting SM. 2004, Horizon Biosience, Norfolk, UK, 193-200.Google Scholar
- Pesce G, Rusciano G, Sirec T, Isticato R, Sasso A, Ricca E: Surface charge and hydrodynamic coefficient measurements ofBacillus subtilisspore by optical tweezers.Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces 2014, 116C:568–575.,Google Scholar
- Nguyen VA, Huynh HA, Hoang TV, Ninh NT, Pham AT, Nguyen HA, Phan TN, Cutting SM: KilledBacillus subtilisspores expressing streptavidin: a novel carrier of drugs to target cancer cells.J Drug Target 2013, 21:528–541.,Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.