Trace element associated reduction of norleucine and norvaline accumulation during oxygen limitation in a recombinant Escherichia coli fermentation
© Biermann et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 24 July 2013
Accepted: 25 October 2013
Published: 21 November 2013
Norleucine and norvaline belong to a group of non-canonical amino acids which are synthesized as byproducts in the branched chain amino acid metabolism of Escherichia coli. The earlier observed misincorporation of these rare amino acids into recombinant proteins has attracted increasing attention due to the rising use of protein based biopharmaceuticals in clinical application. Experimental data revealed pyruvate overflow inducing conditions, which typically occur in oxygen limited zones of large-scale fermentations as a major reason leading to norvaline and norleucine synthesis during E. coli cultivation. Previous approaches to suppress misincorporation of norleucine and norvaline considered growth media supplementation with the relevant canonical isostructural compounds, but no research was performed on the impact of the overflow metabolism related trace elements molybdenum, nickel and selenium. These elements form essential parts of the formate hydrogen lyase (FHL) metalloprotein complex, which is a key enzyme of anaerobic pyruvate metabolism in E. coli and could therefore represent a crucial connection to the pyruvate accumulation associated biosynthesis of rare amino acids.
In this study, the trace element associated response of recombinant antibody producing E. coli to oxygen limitation at high glucose concentration with a special focus on non-canonical amino acids was analysed. During fed-batch cultivation with provoked oxygen limitation and glucose excess norleucine and norvaline were only accumulated in the absence of molybdenum, nickel and selenium. In contrast, the trace element supplemented stress fermentation showed significantly reduced concentrations of these rare amino acids and the major signature fermentation product formate, supporting the correlation between a functional formate hydrogen lyase complex and low unspecific amino acid synthesis under oxygen limitation at high glucose concentration.
The formation of norleucine and norvaline by recombinant E. coli during cultivation with provoked oxygen limitation and glucose excess can be reduced to levels at the detection limit by adding the trace elements molybdenum, selenium and nickel to the fermentation medium. Even under the metabolic burden during induction phase the physiologically available concentrations of non-canonical amino acids remained low. Since our results allow facile process changes that can be easily implemented to avoid the undesirable accumulation of norleucine and norvaline, we consider this study highly interesting for improved process development in E. coli based recombinant drug production and the future development of possible mechanisms to reduce misincorporation events into protein based biopharmaceuticals.
KeywordsEscherichia coli Norleucine Norvaline Trace elements Recombinant antibody Bioprocess design Protein biopharmaceutical Scale-up Scale-down
Beside the 20 canonical amino acids building up proteins in nature, the rare amino acids norleucine and norvaline can be formed by E. coli and some other gram-negative species [1, 2]. Both belonging to a group of branched-chain amino acid analogues, norleucine was originally observed in regulatory mutant strains of Serratia marcescens, whereas norvaline was found to be part of an antifungal peptide secreted by Bacillus subtilis.
More recently non-canonical amino acids have moved into focus when their incorporation into recombinant biopharmaceuticals during expression in E. coli was detected. Prominent cases of therapeutically relevant proteins with confirmed misincorporation are interleukin 2 and human brain derived neurotrophic factor showing norleucine substitutions, as well as recombinant haemoglobin with norvaline sequence variation [4–8].
According to the guidelines of regulatory health authorities like the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and European Medicines Agency (EMA), all of this modified variants of the final drug product need intensive analytical characterization and are therefore highly undesirable in biopharmaceutical production [9, 10]. Furthermore, there is only poor knowledge on the possible deleterious effects of norleucine and norvaline containing protein therapeutics in humans s, especially concerning an unwanted immunogenic response . As a result of the high potential diversity of human antibody reservoir, a by-product induced autoimmune cross-reaction against endogenous proteins could lead to severe health problems in patients [12, 13]. And although the phenomenon of amino acid misincorporation is not regarded as an issue of relevant ICH Q6B guidelines, it most likely becomes a particular regulatory concern due to the increasing number of corresponding reports. In addition to observed by-product formation in E. coli, several cases of translational errors in antibody production via mammalian Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were published quite recently, raising a potentially fundamental problem throughout various expression platforms [14–16]. The molecular event of norleucine and norvaline incorporation into nascent peptide chain basically occurs via misaminoacylation of the cognate tRNA [17, 18]. Following the isostructural properties of norvaline for leucine and norleucine for methionine, tRNAleu and tRNAmet are mischarged by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases producing corresponding substitutions in the protein sequence [19, 20].
The known biosynthesis of norleucine and norvaline in E. coli is facilitated by the promiscuous enzymes of the (iso)-leucine biosynthetic pathway [8, 21, 22]. Allowing the utilization of diverse keto-acid substrates the enzymes isopropylmalate-synthase (LeuA), isopropylmalate-isomerase (LeuCD) and isopropylmalate-dehydrogenase (LeuB) of the leu ABCD-operon are supposed to catalyse a direct chain elongation starting from the central carbon intermediate pyruvate. The enzyme specificity of LeuA in E. coli has not been under investigation yet, but data are available for various substrates of the highly conserved homolog in Salmonella typhimurium which possesses condensation activity for pyruvate with acetyl-CoA . The first extension product 2-ketobutyrate acts as a crucial branched-chain amino acid precursor and is synthesized from threonine under standard conditions. In the subsequent reaction course 2-ketobutyrate is further elongated towards the intermediates 2-ketovalerate and 2-ketocaproate which are finally transaminated to norleucine and norvaline by the aminotransferases IlvE, TyrA and AvtA.
Despite these facts, there exists just a limited understanding of the metabolic conditions leading to the synthesis of non-canonical amino acids in E. coli. Current physiological studies revealed strong evidence for the connection of glucose overflow metabolism and pyruvate accumulation to the occurrence of norvaline in wild-type E. coli fermentations [22, 24]. This is further supported by knock-out experiments showing that deletion of the ilvA gene, which is responsible for 2-ketobutyrate synthesis from threonine, results in significant higher cellular norleucine and norvaline concentrations .
Since the effect of amino acid misincorporation is of main interest in the area of industrial production of biopharmaceuticals, the analysis of recombinant large-scale overflow metabolism related to norleucine and norvaline formation by E. coli is an essential prerequisite for the development of any based process to avoid mistranslation. Furthermore, E. coli represents the major bacterial workhorse for the production of protein therapeutics, currently providing 30% of all FDA and EMA approved recombinant drugs .
Numerous studies describe the metabolic impact of culture heterogeneities as a result of imperfect mixing in large-scale bioprocesses [25, 26], but surprisingly no studies are accomplished on stress induced formation of rare amino acids in recombinant E. coli cultivations related to anaerobic overflow metabolism. With this in mind, our current research was inspired by a report from Soini et al., which discusses the positive influence of additional metal trace elements on anaerobic overflow reactions in E. coli scale-down experiments . The authors showed that media supplementation with selenium, nickel and molybdenum prevents toxic formate accumulation under glucose excess and oxygen limited conditions through a fully functional formate hydrogen lyase enzyme (FHL) complex. However, the experiments of Soini et al. were carried out using the E. coli wild-type strain W3110 without including the additional metabolic burden imposed on cell physiology by synthesizing a heterologous protein. We therefore decided to employ the expression of the well characterized synthetic antibody domain B10 in E. coli RV308 as a relevant example for protein based biopharmaceuticals under current clinical interest . In three representative fed-batch cultivation set-ups the impact of molybdenum, nickel and selenium on norleucine and norvaline accumulation under oxygen limitation and glucose excess provoking conditions was analysed and compared to a control fermentation with sufficient oxygen supply. With this approach we want to further broaden the understanding of norleucine and norvaline accumulation in recombinant E. coli bioprocesses.
In this study we show the reduction of free norleucine and norvaline formation under oxygen limited stress environment by medium supplementation with the FHL-related trace elements. We therefore hypothesize that potential channelling of the pyruvate knot towards formate disproportion may feature a lower production of non-canonical amino acids under large-scale production conditions. Here we report for the first time a trace element associated approach for the reduction of physiologically available unwanted amino acid species in recombinant E. coli fermentation processes.
Results and discussion
Dynamics of growth behaviour and glucose utilization during oxygen downshift experiments
Since the metabolic response towards basic environmental stress factors such as oscillating oxygen or substrate supply may result in reduced productivity [26, 29–31] or causing severe modifications of the desired protein product, a deeper understanding of fundamental mechanisms in relevant biopharmaceutical processes is highly desirable.
In addition, during the oxygen limited cultivation a glucose accumulation of 4 g L-1 glucose without and up to 10 g L-1 glucose with addition of extra trace elements at the end of induction time was observed. These results clearly correspond to earlier studies, showing a strong inhibition on growth and glucose consumption when E. coli is impaired with both, metabolic burden of recombinant expression and overflow metabolism [27, 32, 33].
Reduction of norleucine and norvaline accumulation by medium supplementation with molybdenum, nickel and selenium
Differences in formate accumulation and recombinant expression of antibody domain B10
Analysis of recombinant protein yield, OD 600nm at end of cultivation and stirrer rate during expression phase of E. coli RV308 B10
Maximum stirrer speed (RPM)
Protein yield (mg/L)
Oxygen downshift + Mo, Ni, Se
Connecting these findings with significantly lowered norleucine and norvaline accumulation in the respective fermentation scenarios, one might hypothesize that a functional FHL enzyme complex can channel the pyruvate flux to disproportion of formate and avoiding accumulation of unspecific precursors for non-canonical amino acids [24, 34].
In this study we could clearly show the trace element associated reduction of norleucine and norvaline accumulation during oxygen downshift experiments of biopharmaceutical relevant recombinant E. coli fermentations. We identified the elements molybdenum, nickel and selenium as key cultivation medium components reducing the formation of non-canonical amino acids under oxygen limitation and glucose excess. Our findings might contribute to the development of new strategies to avoid norleucine and norvaline misincorporation into protein based drugs and further improve recombinant pharmaceutical production in accordance to current international guidelines.
The strain used in this study was Escherichia coli K-12 RV308 ATCC 31608x [su-, ΔlacX74, gal IS II::OP308, strA] transformed with plasmid p41B10aP . Stock solution of the strain was stored in 25% [v/v] glycerol solution supplemented with mineral salt medium.
All precultures were cultivated at 30°C on a rotary shaker set to 200 rpm. The initial precultures were performed in 10 mL of LB medium supplemented with ampicillin (100 μg mL-1) in 100 mL Erlenmeyer flasks for 8–12 hours inoculated with E. coli stock solution. The second precultures for inoculation of bioreactors were performed in 1000 mL Erlenmeyer flasks filled with 100 mL of the respective bioreactor mineral salt medium supplemented with 10 g L-1 glucose.
The fed-batch cultivations were performed in a Sixfors bioreactor (Infors, Switzerland) equipped with DCU-3 controlling unit and MFCS-monitoring system (Sartorius, Germany) starting with 0.4 L working volume. Main cultures were inoculated with liquid precultures to a starting OD600 of 0.15. The defined mineral salt cultivation medium was prepared in distilled water containing per L: 8.6 g Na2HPO4 × 12 H2O, 0.5 g NaCl, 3 g KH2PO4, 1 g NH4Cl, 10 mL Fe-citrate (0.023 M), 0.1 mL EDTA (0.2 M), 0.1 mL CoCl2 × 6 H2O (0.1 M), 0.1 mL MnCl2 × 4 H2O (0.75 M), 0.1 mL CuCl2 × 4 H2O (0.1 M), 0.1 mL H3BO3 (0.5 M), 2 mL Zn(CH3COO)2 × 2 H2O (0.018 M), 5 mL MgSO4 (1 M), 0.1 g thiamine hydrochlorid and 1 mL antifoam agent. In order to examine the effect of medium supplementation with molybdenum, nickel and selenium, these additional trace elements were initially added to the indicated cultivation to a final concentration of: 0.24 mg L-1 Na2Mo × 5 H2O, 1.45 mg L-1 Ni(NO3)2 × 6 H2O and 0.17 mg L-1 Na2SeO3 × 5 H2O . The cultivation temperature was 30°C and pH was kept at 6.8 by controlled feeding of 10% ammoniumhydroxid. The fermentation media contained an initial glucose concentration of 15 g L-1, the feed solution contained 500 g L-1 glucose. Reference cultivation was performed in glucose limited fed-batch mode with controlled DOT set point at 30%. The metabolic shift in scale-down fermentations was initialized at the end of exponential growth phase by lowering the stirrer rate from 1000 rpm to 500 rpm. The glucose feeding was started 20 min after stirrer downshift with a constant rate of 10 g L-1 h-1 to ensure glucose excess during the whole cultivation. For protein expression, cultures were induced with 1 mM IPTG.
Analysis of cell growth
Cell growth was monitored by measurement of absorbance (OD600nm) with a Spekol spectrophotometer (Carl Zeiss, Germany).
Amino acid analysis
Fermentation samples for amino acid analysis of clarified crude broth lysates were immediately quenched in −40°C cold 60% methanol and subsequently shock-frozen in liquid nitrogen. Samples were stored at −80°C until analysis. The sample preparation for HPLC included dilution of samples to the same cell density with 0.9% NaCl, a subsequent sonification step for 10 min on ice, removal of cell debris and deproteinization by centrifugation for 10 min (4°C, 16.000 × g) and ultracentrifugation of supernatant using Amicon Ultra 3 kDa cut-filter devices (Millipore. The HPLC analysis was performed with a JASCO X-LC HPLC system (JASCO Corporation, Japan), containing autosampler unit, intelligent column thermostat, fluorescence detector and a Nucleodur C18 Gravity column (Macherey-Nagel, Germany). Pre-column derivatization of 30 μL sample solution and 30 μL OPA reagent (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany) was carried out for 30 s in autosampler unit, followed by injection of 1 μL onto column. HPLC analysis was further performed as described earlier .
Analysis of glucose and formate
Glucose and formate concentrations were analysed from medium samples, which were immediately centrifuged for 5 min (4°C, 16.000 × g), filtered (0.2 μm) and shock-frozen in liquid nitrogen. Glucose was analysed with ECA 2000 unit (YSI Life Sciences, USA). Formate was analysed with Formiat Assay Kit (Bio Vision, Germany).
Quantification of B10aP
Determination of correctly folded B10aP was performed by enzyme activity assay and calculated by means of a standard curve. Colorimetric detection was performed with the PNPP (p-nitrophenyl phosphate, disodium salt) substrate (Pierce) for alkaline phosphatase. Samples of 1 mL were taken before and every hour during induction phase, followed by immediate shock-freezing in liquid nitrogen, sonification for 10 min on ice and removal of cell debris by centrifugation.
The authors acknowledge their sincere gratitude to JSMC, Wacker Biotech GmbH and the DFG for funding the project.
- Kisumi M, Sugiura M, Kato J, Chibata I: L-Norvaline and L-homoisoleucine formation by Serratia marcescens. J Biochem. 1976, 79 (5): 1021-1028.Google Scholar
- Suguira M, Kisumi M, Chibata I: Biosynthetic pathway of beta-methylnorleucine, an antimetabolite produced by Serrati marcescens. J Antibiot. 1981, 34: 1283-1289. 10.7164/antibiotics.34.1283.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nandi P, Sen GP: An antifungal substance from a strain of Bacillus subtilis. Nature. 1953, 172: 871-872.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Apostol I, Levine J, Lippincott J, Leach J, Hess E, Glascock CB, Weickert MJ, Blackmore R: Incorporation of norvaline at leucine positions in recombinant human hemoglobin expressed in Escherichia coli. J Biol Chem. 1997, 272: 28980-28988. 10.1074/jbc.272.46.28980.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lu HS, Tsai LB, Kenney WC, Lai PH: Identification of unusual replacement of methionine by norleucine in recombinant interleukin-2 produced by E. coli. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 1988, 156: 807-813. 10.1016/S0006-291X(88)80916-1.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tsai LB, Lu HS, Kenney WC, Curless CC, Klein ML, Lai PH, Fenton DM, Altrock BW, Mann MB: Control of misincorporation of de novo synthesized norleucine into recombinant interleukin-2 in E. coli. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 1988, 156: 733-739. 10.1016/S0006-291X(88)80904-5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sunasara KM, Cramer SM, Hauer CR, Rupp RG, Shoup VA: Characterization of recombinant human brain-derived neurotrophic factor variants. Arch Biochem Biophys. 1999, 372 (2): 248-260. 10.1006/abbi.1999.1501.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bogosian G, Violand BN, Dorward-King EJ, Workman WE, Jung PE, Kane JF: Biosynthesis and incorporation into protein of norleucine by Escherichia coli. J Biol Chem. 1998, 264: 531-539.Google Scholar
- Berkowitz SA, Engen JR, Mazzeo JR, Jones GB: Analytical tools for characterizing biopharmaceuticals and the implications for biosimilars. Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2012, 11 (7): 527-540. 10.1038/nrd3746.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ahmed I, Kaspar B, Sharma U: Biosimilars: impact of biologic product life cycle and European experience on the regulatory trajectory in the United States. Clin Ther. 2012, 34 (2): 400-419. 10.1016/j.clinthera.2011.12.005.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kurland C, Gallant J: Errors of heterologous protein expression. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 1996, 7 (5): 489-493. 10.1016/S0958-1669(96)80050-4.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Rosenberger RF: Translational errors during recombinant protein synthesis. Dev Biol Stand. 1994, 83: 21-26.Google Scholar
- Yang Y, Strahan A, Li C, Shem A, Liu H, Ouyang J, Katta V, Francissen K, Zhang B: Detecting low level sequence variants in recombinant monoclonal antibodies. mAbs. 2010, 2 (3): 285-289. 10.4161/mabs.2.3.11718.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yu XC, Borisov OV, Alvarez M, Michels DA, Wang YJ, Ling V: Identification of codon-specific serine to asparagine mistranslation in recombinant monoclonal antibodies by high-resolution mass spectrometry. Anal Chem. 2009, 81 (22): 9282-9290. 10.1021/ac901541h.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zeck A, Regula JT, Larraillet V, Mautz B, Popp O, Göpfert U, Wiegeshoff F, Vollertsen U, Gorr IH, Koll H, Papadimitriou A: Low Level Sequence Variant Analysis of Recombinant Proteins: an optimized approach. PLos One. 2012, 7 (7): e40328-10.1371/journal.pone.0040328.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Reynolds NM, Lazazzera BA, Ibba M: Cellular mechanisms that control mistranslation. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2010, 12: 849-856.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yadavalli SS, Ibba M: Selection of tRNA charging quality control mechanisms that increase mistranslation of the genetic code. Nucleic Acids Res. 2013, 41 (2): 1104-1112. 10.1093/nar/gks1240.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Budisa N, Steipe B, Demange P, Eckerskorn C, Kellermann J, Huber R: High-level biosynthetic substitution of methionine in proteins by its analogs 2-aminohexanoic acid, selenomethionine, telluromethionine and ethionine in Escherichia coli. Eur J Biochem. 1995, 230: 788-796. 10.1111/j.1432-1033.1995.tb20622.x.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hoesl MG, Budisa N: Recent advances in genetic code engineering in Escherichia coli. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 2012, 23: 751-757. 10.1016/j.copbio.2011.12.027.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sycheva EV, Yampol’skaya TA, Preobrajenskaya ES, Novikova AE, Matrosov NG, Stoynova NV: Overproduction of noncanonical amino acids by Escherichia coli cells. Mikrobiologiya. 2007, 76 (6): 805-812.Google Scholar
- Soini J, Falschlehner C, Liedert C, Bernhardt J, Vuoristo J, Neubauer P: Norvaline is accumulated after a down-shift of oxygen in Escherichia coli W3110. Microb Cell Fact. 2008, 7: 30-10.1186/1475-2859-7-30.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kohlhaw G, Leary TR, Umbarger HE: Alpha-isopropylmalate synthase from Salmonella typhimurium. Purification and properties. J Biol Chem. 1969, 244: 2218-2225.Google Scholar
- Soini J, Ukkonen K, Neubauer P: Accumulation of amino acids deriving from pyruvate in Escherichia coli W3110 during fed-batch cultivation in a two-compartment scale-down bioreactor. Adv Biosci Biotechnol. 2011, 2: 336-339. 10.4236/abb.2011.25049.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Huang CJ, Lin H, Yang X: Industrial production of recombinant therapeutics in Escherichia coli and its recent advancements. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol. 2012, 39 (3): 383-399. 10.1007/s10295-011-1082-9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Takors R: Scale-up of microbial processes: impacts, tools and open questions. J Biotechnol. 2012, 160 (1–2): 3-9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Neubauer P, Junne S: Scale-down simulators for metabolic analysis of large-scale bioprocesses. biotechnology. 2010, 21 (1): 114-121.Google Scholar
- Soini J, Ukkonen K, Neubauer P: High cell density media for Escherichia coli are generally designed for aerobic cultivations – consequences for large-scale bioprocesses and shake flask cultures. Microb Cell Fact. 2008, 7: 26-10.1186/1475-2859-7-26.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Habicht G, Haupt C, Friedrich RP, Hortschansky P, Sachse C, Meinhardt J, Wieligmann K, Gellermann GP, Brodhun M, Götz J, Halbhuber KJ, Röcken C, Horn U, Fändrich M: Directed selection of a conformational antibody domain that prevents mature amyloid fibril formation by stabilizing Aβ protofibrils. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2007, 104 (49): 19232-19237. 10.1073/pnas.0703793104.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Carneiro S, Ferreira EC, Rocha I: Metabolic responses to recombinant bioprocesses in Escherichia coli. J Biotechnol. 2013, 164 (3): 396-408. 10.1016/j.jbiotec.2012.08.026.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Trotter EW, Rolfe MD, Hounslow AM, Craven CJ, Williamson MP, Sanguinetti G, Poole RK, Green J: Reprogramming of Escherichia coli K-12 metabolism during the initial phase of transition from an anaerobic to a micro-aerobic environment. PLoS One. 2011, 6 (9): e25501-10.1371/journal.pone.0025501.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hewitt CJ, Onyeaka H, Lewis G, Taylor IW, Nienow AW: A comparison of high cell density fed-batch fermentations involving both induced and non-induced recombinant Escherichia coli under well-mixed small-scale and simulated poorly mixed large-scale conditions. Biotechnol Bioeng. 2007, 96 (3): 495-505. 10.1002/bit.21127.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beyer L, Doberenz C, Falke D, Hunger D, Suppmann B, Sawers RG: Coordination of FocA and pyruvate formate-lyase synthesis in Escherichia coli demonstrates preferential translocation of formate over other mixed-acid fermentation products. J Bacteriol. 2013, 195 (7): 1428-1435. 10.1128/JB.02166-12.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pinske C, Bönn M, Krüger S, Lindenstrauß U, Sawers RG: Metabolic deficiences revealed in the biotechnologically important model Bacterium Escherichia coli BL21(DE3). PLos One. 2011, 6 (8): e22830-10.1371/journal.pone.0022830.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Biermann M, Bardl B, Vollstädt S, Linnemann J, Knüpfer U, Seidel G, Horn U: Simultaneous analysis of the non-canonical amino acids norleucine and norvaline in biopharmaceutical-related fermentation processes by a new ultra-high performance liquid chromatography approach. Amino Acids. 2013, 44 (4): 1225-1231. 10.1007/s00726-013-1459-3.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.