- Technical notes
- Open Access
Monitoring and external control of pH in microfluidic droplets during microbial culturing
Microbial Cell Factories volume 19, Article number: 16 (2020)
Cell-based experimentation in microfluidic droplets is becoming increasingly popular among biotechnologists and microbiologists, since inherent characteristics of droplets allow high throughput at low cost and space investment. The range of applications for droplet assays is expanding from single cell analysis toward complex cell–cell incubation and interaction studies. As a result of cellular metabolism in these setups, relevant physicochemical alterations frequently occur before functional assays are conducted. However, to use droplets as truly miniaturized bioreactors, parameters like pH and oxygen availability should be controlled similar to large-scale fermentation to ensure reliable research.
Here, we introduce a comprehensive strategy to monitor and control pH for large droplet populations during long-term incubation. We show the correlation of fluorescence intensity of 6-carboxyfluorescein and pH in single droplets and entire droplet populations. By taking advantage of inter-droplet transport of pH-mediating molecules, the average pH value of several million droplets is simultaneously adjusted in an a priori defined direction. To demonstrate the need of pH control in practice, we compared the fermentation profiles of two E. coli strains, a K12-strain and a B-strain, in unbuffered medium with 5 g/L glucose for standard 1 L bioreactors and 180 pL droplets. In both fermentation formats, the commonly used B-strain E. coli BL21 is able to consume glucose until depletion and prevent a pH drop, while the growth of the K12-strain E. coli MG1655 is soon inhibited by a low pH caused by its own high acetate production. By regulating the pH during fermentation in droplets with our suggested strategy, we were able to prevent the growth arrest of E. coli MG1655 and obtained an equally high biomass yield as with E. coli BL21.
We demonstrated a comparable success of pH monitoring and regulation for fermentations in 1 L scale and 180 pL scale for two E. coli strains. This strategy has the potential to improve cell-based experiments for various microbial systems in microfluidic droplets and opens the possibility for new functional assay designs.
In the past decades, microbiological experimentation experienced a quantum leap due to the development of various novel molecular and analytical techniques. As a secondary consequence, these advances have deviated the attention away from classic aspects of microbiology, particularly thorough control of cultivation conditions . Nevertheless, the fundamental principles and craftsmanship that have been already established for lab scale microbial cultivation should be considered for any novel experimental method development, including miniaturized cell cultivation and single cell studies .
Among innovative experimental strategies, droplet microfluidics has the potential to revolutionize microbiological experimentation , enabling ultra-high throughput of single cell or micro cultivation experiments, as well as of genomic and metabolomic approaches. Yet, two key parameters that must be monitored and controlled for robust microbiological investigations, even in picoliter droplets, are oxygen availability and pH. In particular, pH changes can indicate different metabolic compounds produced and drastically alter the cell phenotype, potentially affecting further growth or perturbing extracellular reactions. Usually pH and oxygen concentration are thoroughly monitored and controlled during standard culturing. Stirring and aeration are used to control oxygen availability, while buffers and feedback loops are widely applied to adjust pH during cultivation in automated bioreactors. However, monitoring and controlling these variables is more complex at small scales. Due to the highly reduced volume of microfluidic droplets (from pL to µL), the challenge of sensor miniaturization arises. Furthermore, such sensors must be inert and biocompatible, and provide sensitive and non-destructive measurements at such minute scale.
Using oxygen sensitive nanoparticles, we demonstrated in previous work how to monitor oxygen supply for millions of droplets simultaneously . Moreover, we developed a simple strategy for active oxygenation by flushing oil through the droplet population, which results in enhanced and homogeneous oxygen availability during incubation. The improved oxygenation, for the first time, provided a microbial cultivation platform in the picoliter scale that resulted in similar growth and production yields as observed in shaking flask cultures, bridging classic microbiological craftsmanship to microfluidic droplets.
Beyond this, a strategy for pH monitoring and control is also of high importance for microbiological experimentation in droplets. Here, we endeavor to expand our strategy to include the detection and control of pH in millions of droplets simultaneously.
Results and discussion
pH monitoring with 6-carboxyfluorescein in single droplets and populations
Our method for pH estimation is based on the dependency of the fluorescence intensity of dyes on the pH. In previous studies, estimation of the pH in single droplets using sensitive fluorescent dyes has been performed to detect the production of lactate by single cells [4,5,6]. The usage of 6-carboxyfluorescein dissolved in the aqueous phase at a concentration of 2 µg/mL provides a facile method for pH estimation as demonstrated with a calibration curve of droplet fluorescence intensity obtained at different pH values of the bulk aqueous phase (pH was adjusted with HCl or NaOH). As expected, the correlation of fluorescence intensity and pH value follows a sigmoidal dose response curve around the pKa of 6-carboxyfluorescein, enabling monitoring of pH in the range of 5.5–7.5 (Fig. 1a). The fluorescence intensity was determined for single droplets in flow by focusing a 488 nm laser on the microfluidic channel and detecting the emitted signal with a photomultiplier tube (PMT), resolving the approximate pH value for single droplets. To monitor the average pH value of an entire droplet population periodically, one option is to transfer the emulsion into an appropriate microtiter plate for measuring the average fluorescence intensity in a plate reader (Fig. 1b) for a fast implementation approach. As second option, the dynamic droplet incubation setup  can be augmented with an excitation source and a detection unit for fluorescence light allowing controlled incubation of droplets regarding oxygen supply and pH with facile connection to reinjection of the droplet population for downstream unit operations in microfluidic chips (Fig. 1c).
For all measurement options, the fluorescent signal is subject to interference caused by media components and variability during long-term experimentation due to the photo-instability of the dye. Hence, we optimized the measurement parameters like intensity of excitation light and length of measurement intervals in order to minimize fluorescence bleaching.
Inter-droplet transport of pH mediating molecules
Very little is known about the behavior of pH mediating molecules in microfluidic emulsions with perfluorinated oils and surfactants. However, observations from Boitard et al.  suggest that protonated, organic acid molecules can diffuse out of the droplets. Therefore, we evaluated pH changes due to inter-droplet transport [8, 9] when incubating two distinct populations together. Each population contained unbuffered medium with 6-carboxyfluorescein at pH 6 or 7.5, respectively. Fluorescence intensity was measured droplet by droplet upon generation or reinjection (Fig. 2a). While droplets of the separated populations clearly present distinct fluorescent intensities, the intensities in the mixed population converge toward an intermediate value within seconds after mixing (2B). After 5 min, the populations in the mix can still be recognized in the histogram, albeit much closer than when separated. Further incubation together for 16 h resulted in completely undiscernible populations (Fig. 2c). This means that molecules and possibly even ions that change the pH can readily move between droplets.
Employing inter-droplet transport for pH regulation
It has been recently shown that acidic compounds in the fluorinated oil are able to change the pH inside droplets [6, 10]. This, in line with our results on inter-droplet transport of pH molecules, can be exploited as a strategy to control the pH in an incubated droplet population. We show that acetic acid and diethylamine can be used to either decrease or increase pH in droplet populations. The measured fluorescence strongly changed as a result of spiking the recirculation oil with acetic acid or diethylamine both when measuring the average fluorescence value for a large sample of droplets in a microtiter plate, and when reinjecting and analyzing droplet by droplet (Fig. 2d). This confirms that these compounds can be used to externally control the pH inside of the incubated droplets.
Model system for pH regulation during microbial droplet culture
In order to test the applicability of droplet pH regulation, we tested the fermentation profiles of various E. coli strains, which are known to alter pH and are affected by it. When cultured in unbuffered media with glucose, the growth of E. coli MG1655 is truncated when the pH reaches 5.5 (Fig. 3b), presumably as a consequence of its own high production of acetate . Contrarily, E. coli BL21 does not reach the same low pH due to a more restricted acetate production or simultaneous acetate consumption, as suggested by higher gene expression levels for the glyoxylate cycle  and the acetyl-CoA synthetase . Since acetate levels are kept stable at a low level of approximately 0.6 g/L, the pH does not fall below 6.4. Cell propagation continues until glucose is depleted (Fig. 3a). Then, cells additionally consume the secreted acetate and amino acids, which were likely dissimilated already in parallel to glucose before . This results in further pH increase and more than twice the cell density. When performing the fermentation with pH control at a threshold at pH 6.5, the growth arrest of E. coli MG1655 is prevented even though acetate is still produced in high concentrations. By controlling the pH, E. coli MG1655 can consume the entire amount of glucose and reaches a similar optical density as E. coli BL21 (Fig. 3c, d).
The same tendency is observed when these strains are grown in microfluidic droplets incubated with the enhanced dynamic droplet incubation setup. The pH change is observed by following the green fluorescence intensity of the 6-carboxyfluorescein coencapsulated with the cells (4A). Based on measurements with a standard pH electrode before droplet generation, cultures for both strains start at a pH of approx. 6.5. For E. coli MG1655, the pH decreases within 4 h, similar to the observations in the bioreactor culture. E. coli BL21 also follows the same profile as in larger scaled culture, with an initial drop in pH and the subsequent increment of pH. Not only the development of the pH, but also the incomplete consumption of glucose by E. coli MG1655 and the reduced yield in biomass were reproduced in droplet cultivation (Fig. 4b). As a confirmation for the pH estimates obtained from fluorescence intensity monitoring, we also measured the pH with a pH electrode after droplet incubation and controlled emulsion breakage of the droplet population in the continous aqueous phase. As expected, the values are congruent to the expected trend and further strengthen our hypothesis regarding an equivalent bioprocess in pL droplets as in 1 L fermentations.
Adding minute amounts of diethylamine dissolved in oil to the continuous phase of droplet incubation via the oil reservoir of the recirculation setup results in homogeneous mixing of the modified oil with the droplet population and subsequent in control of the pH inside the droplets (Fig. 5a and Additional file 1: Figure S1). As expected, this enables E. coli MG1655 to grow further and reach similarly high cell densities as E. coli BL21. The complete consumption of glucose and the neutral pH is also in agreement with the higher biomass yield (Fig. 5b). Consequently, the observed bioprocess in pL droplets is equivalent to the course of the large-scale fermentation (Fig. 3). Also, when the regulation of pH is started at different time points during cultivation, the auto-recovery of neutral pH by E. coli MG1655 is restored (Additional file 1: Figure S1).
Here, continuous recirculation of the fluorinated oil ensures not only proper oxygenation, but serves as steerable carrier for the pH controlling molecules and a homogeneous mixing strategy. The addition of pH controlling acid or base can further be automated with a feedback loop according to the measurement provided by the fluorescence detector coupled to the droplet incubator.
Here, we present a strategy that exploits inter-droplet transport to regulate pH inside picoliter droplets. We exemplify this strategy with the model organism E. coli, but it is applicable to all microbial cultivations in picoliter droplets. In most droplet microfluidic applications, populations consisting of thousands or millions of droplets are generated and incubated, from which particular variants should be distinguished in the context of a functional assay. However, cell propagation and reactions taking place in droplets are affected by pH changes even when those changes occur only in a fraction of the whole droplet population. Ignoring this issue leads to unreproducible and inconsistent results. Our strategy enables scientists to standardize conditions in droplets for physiological experimentation. Furthermore, new options in assay development can be exploited, since pH ranges can now be adjusted to select enzymes or microbes with activity at adverse or changing pH conditions. As most fluorescent dyes can be affected by changes in pH, it is also extremely useful to have the possibility to readjust the pH to values that allow optimal quantification in droplets. Controlled pH changes can also be used to trigger reactions in droplets  or other transport-mediated functionalities . The possibility to regulate or rapidly change pH can also be crucial for chemical and nanoparticle synthesis applications in droplets .
The proposed strategy is a valuable feature for improved microbiological experimentation and screening assays in picoliter droplets. In fact, the possibility to control oxygen and pH reduces the experimental gap between microfluidic and larger scaled experimentation, such as performed in microtiter plates and bioreactors.
Droplets were generated in a flow focusing unit on custom made PDMS chips by using syringe pumps (neMESYS, CETONI, Germany). Novec HFE7500 oil (3 M, Germany) with 0.5% surfactant (PicoSurf 1, Dolomite, UK) was used as perfluorinated, immiscible phase. The aqueous phase consisted of buffer or culture media with cells and 6-carboxyfluorescein. Droplets were collected and incubated in 3D printed incubators at 28 °C,  or in wells of microtiter plates at 500 rpm double orbital and 28 °C. Droplets were imaged immobile in chambers on PDMS chips with ×10 and ×40 magnification using a PCO edge camera (PCO AG, Germany).
Bulk pH measurements for validation were performed with a conventional pH microelectrode (Mettler Toledo, Germany). For calibrations, pH was adjusted using 1 M NaOH (Roth, Germany) or 1 M HCl (Roth Germany).
6-carboxyfluorescein (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany), dissolved in 100% (v/v) DMSO, was diluted to a final concentration of 2 µg/mL in the aqueous phase. A 488 nm diode laser (LASOS Lasertechnik, Germany) was focused downstream of generation or reinjection structure on the microfluidic channel through which droplets flowed. Emitted light was collected by the optics of an inverse microscope (Axio Observer.Z1, Carl Zeiss, Germany) and detected by a photomultiplier module (H10721-20, Hamamatsu Photonics, Japan). For measurement of average pH in droplet population by 6-carboxyfluorescein, the entire droplet population was transferred to a standard black 96-well plate with clear bottom (Greiner Bio-One, Germany), which was sealed by a polyester film (Excel Scientific, Germany) to avoid evaporation. During longterm monitoring, the seals were perforated for oxygenation. Fluorescence intensity in plates was determined by a multimode plate reader (ClarioStar, BMG Labtech, Germany) at 486/8 nm excitation and 526/20 nm emission.
The dynamic droplet incubation setup was slightly modified (Additional file 1: Figure S2) by integrating holders for the excitation light source (Lumencor Spectra-X, USA) liquid light-guide and emitted light collection fiber (Pyroscience, Germany). Both are aligned toward the center of the droplet incubator, where droplets are always present and constantly recirculating. A laser clean up filter (AHF, Germany) was used to strongly restrict the excitation light to 488/4 nm. The collected emitted light was filtered with a 525/50 bandpass (Thorlabs) and detected with a photodiode. To minimize photobleaching, the light source was programmed to turn on for a second every 10 min.
pH control in droplets
For increasing the pH in droplet populations, pure diethylamine (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany) was added to the perfluorinated oil with surfactant at working concentration in a ratio of 1:100. This conditioned oil was subsequently added stepwise to a droplet population in a ratio of 1:200.
For acidifying a droplet population, the perfluorinated oil was treated with acetic acid (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany) in the same way as described above.
Escherichia coli strains BL21 and MG1655 were stored at − 20 °C as cryo stocks containing 50% (v/v) of glycerol preservation medium. Cultivation was performed in unbuffered soy peptone yeast extract medium (SY) containing 5 g/L soy peptone (BD Difco, Germany), 5 g/L yeast extract (BD Difco, Germany) and 5 g/L NaCl (Roth, Germany) in aqua dest. Initial pH was adjusted to 6.75 before autoclaving for 20 min at 121 °C. Before usage, SY was complemented with 3 g/L sterile glucose (VWR international, Germany) for precultures or 5 g/L glucose for main cultures. Fresh medium was inoculated from first preculture to a start OD600 of 0.1 and incubated at 28 °C in glass Erlenmeyer flasks at 160 rpm until reaching mid exponential phase. Before droplet generation, cell suspensions were washed and diluted in SY medium + 5 g/L glucose to the starting cell concentration of OD600 0.1.
Culture in 1 L bioreactors
As described above, 2 precultures of both E. coli strains were produced to activate and synchronize the metabolism. 100 mL of the second preculture at OD600 1 were used to inoculate 900 mL SY + 5 g/L glucose in Biostat B-DCU II bioreactors (Sartorius, Germany). The fermentations were carried out for 24 h at 28 °C with 600 rpm constant stirring and 0.5 L/min aeration. pH, pO2, temperature, air flow and stirring speed were continuously monitored online during the fermentation. For the offline determination of cell density, glucose and acetate concentration, a sample of 15 mL was taken under sterile conditions every 1.5 h. Glucose concentration was determined immediately with a YSI 2900 Biochemistry Analyzer (YSI Incorporated, USA) following the manufacturer protocol. Acetate concentration was determined by HPLC (Jasco, Germany) with an Aminex HPX-87H Ion Exclusion Column (Bio-Rad, USA), for which samples were stored at − 20 °C upon measurement. For pH regulation, 2 M diethylamine in aqua bidest was fed automatically into the fermenter through a pH control unit to prevent the pH from dropping below 6.5.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article. The datasets are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Egli T. Microbial growth and physiology: a call for better craftsmanship. Front Microbiol. 2015;06:287.
Kaminski T, Scheler O, Garstecki P. Droplet microfluidics for microbiology: techniques, applications and challenges. Lab Chip. 2016;16:2168–87.
Mahler L, Tovar M, Weber T, Brandes S, Rudolph M, Ehgartner J, et al. Enhanced and homogeneous oxygen availability during incubation of microfluidic droplets. RSC Adv. 2015;5:101871–8.
Mongersun A, Smeenk I, Pratx G, Asuri P, Abbyad P. Droplet microfluidic platform for the determination of single-cell lactate release. Anal Chem. 2016;88:3257–63.
Del Ben F, Turetta M, Celetti G, Piruska A, Bulfoni M, Cesselli D, et al. A method for detecting circulating tumor cells based on the measurement of single-cell metabolism in droplet-based microfluidics. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2016;55:8581–4.
Riechers B, Maes F, Akoury E, Semin B, Gruner P, Baret J-C. Surfactant adsorption kinetics in microfluidics. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2016;113:11465–70.
Boitard L, Cottinet D, Kleinschmitt C, Bremond N, Baudry J, Yvert G, et al. Monitoring single-cell bioenergetics via the coarsening of emulsion droplets. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2012;109:7181–6.
Gruner P, Riechers B, Semin B, Lim J, Johnston A, Short K, et al. Controlling molecular transport in minimal emulsions. Nat Commun. 2016;7:10392.
Skhiri Y, Gruner P, Semin B, Brosseau Q, Pekin D, Mazutis L, et al. Dynamics of molecular transport by surfactants in emulsions. Soft Matter. 2012;8:10618–27.
Mashaghi S, van Oijen A. External control of reactions in microdroplets. Sci Rep. 2015;5:11837.
Yoon S, Han M, Jeong H, Lee C, Xia X, Lee D, et al. Comparative multi-omics systems analysis of Escherichia coli strains B and K-12. Genome Biol. 2012;13:R37.
Marisch K, Bayer K, Scharl T, Mairhofer J, Krempl PM, Hummel K, et al. A comparative analysis of industrial Escherichia coli K-12 and B strains in high-glucose batch cultivations on process-, transcriptome- and proteome level. PLoS ONE. 2013;8:e70516.
Leone S, Sannino F, Tutino ML, Parrilli E, Picone D. Acetate: friend or foe? Efficient production of a sweet protein in Escherichia coli BL21 using acetate as a carbon source. Microb Cell Fact. 2015;14:106.
Karbaschi M, Shahi P, Abate AR. Rapid, chemical-free breaking of microfluidic emulsions with a hand-held antistatic gun. Biomicrofluidics. 2017;11:044107.
Shang L, Cheng Y, Zhao Y. Emerging droplet microfluidics. Chem Rev. 2017;117:7964–8040.
The authors thank Michael Cyrulies for technical assistance with cultures in bioreactors and Bettina Bardl for performing the analytics for acetate and glucose concentration.
This work was supported by the Free State of Thuringia-project no. 2017FE9071, which was co-financed by the European Union through the European Regional Development Fund (EFRE), and the Jena School for Microbial Communication (JSMC) funded by the German Excellence Initiative.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Additional file 1: Figure S1. Repetitions of E. coli MG1655 cultured in droplets under pH regulation. Droplet populations were incubated in customized droplet incubators. Fluorescence of 6-carboxyfluorescein was monitored constantly as indication for pH development. When the fluorescence signal dropped below a value of 1, diethylamine dissolved in a ratio of 1:100 in the perfluorinated oil with surfactant at working concentration was administered by pipetting to the droplet population. The fluorescence intensity is monitored over time for 3 replicates. Each droplet population contained E. coli MG1655 with the same starting cell density. Cell densities were measured at the end of the experiment after breaking the droplets, resulting in OD600 of 8.8, 7.63 and 7.8 respectively. The onset and course of the manual base dosage was chosen individually for each experiment. On the second y axis the cumulative amount of diethylamine treated oil added during the incubation is plotted. Figure S2. Dynamic droplet incubation with pH monitoring and control setup. Optical fibers are used to bring excitation light into the droplet incubator. Emitted light is collected with another fiber and the signal is measured in a photodiode. The oil reservoir is used to add the pH modifying molecules (diethylamine or acetic acid) already diluted in perfluorinated oil.
About this article
Cite this article
Tovar, M., Mahler, L., Buchheim, S. et al. Monitoring and external control of pH in microfluidic droplets during microbial culturing. Microb Cell Fact 19, 16 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12934-020-1282-y
- Droplet microfluidics
- pH regulation
- Inter-droplet transport
- E. coli K12- and B-strain
- Miniaturized fermentation