From: Strategies for improving the production of bio-based vanillin
Substrate | Microorganisms | Scale | Titer | Yield | Productivity | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ferulic acid | B. subtilis B7-S | Bioreactor | 379Â mg/L | 0.63Â g/g ferulic acid | / | [55] |
 | P. fluorescens BF13-1p4 with pBB1 | Bioreactor | 1.28 g/L | 84.1% (molar yield) | / | [15] |
 | Streptomyces sp. V-1 | Bioreactor | 19.20 g/L | 0.43 g/g ferulic acid | / | [16] |
 | E. coli DH5α with pTAHEF | Bioreactor | 1.12 g/L | 0.78 g/g ferulic acid | / | [58] |
 | E. coli NTG-VR1 | Flask | 2.90 g/L | 0.29 g/g ferulic acid | / | [29] |
 | E. coli JM109-FE-F | Bioreactor | 2.28 g/L | 75.0% (molar yield) | 0.126 g/L/h | [43] |
 | E. coli DH5α (ΔicdA) with pTAHEF-gltA | Bioreactor | 5.14 g/L | 86.6% (molar yield) | / | [38] |
 | E. coli VA1 with pETDuet-fcs-ech | Bioreactor | / | 86.7% (molar yield) | 1.10 g/L/h | [49] |
 | Amycolatopsis sp. ATCC 39,116 | Bioreactor | 7.76 g/L | 0.69 g/g ferulic acid | 0.46 g/L/h | [56] |
 | Amycolatopsis sp. ATCC 39,116 | Flask | 9.18 g/L | 96.1% (molar yield) | / | [59] |
 | Amycolatopsis sp. ATCC 39,116 Δvdh::permE*::echfcs with utilization of resin | Bioreactor | 22.30 g/L | / | / | [60] |
 | Streptomyces V1 | Flask | 9.09 g/L | 95.2% (molar yield) | / | [59] |
Eugenol | Bacillus safensis SMS 1003 | Bioreactor | 120Â mg/L | 26.0% (molar yield) | / | [14] |
 | P. resinovorans SPR1 | Bioreactor | 240 mg/L | 10.0% (molar yield) | / | [22] |
 | Pseudomonas sp. HRvdhΩKm | Bioreactor | 441 mg/L | 44.6% (molar yield) | / | [25] |
Isoeugenol | B. pumilus S-1 | Bioreactor | 3.75Â g/L | 40.5% (molar yield) | / | [18] |
 | Pseudomonas sp. ISPC2 | Bioreactor | 1.15 g/L | 12.4% (molar yield) | / | [19] |
 | Psychrobacter sp. CSW4 | Bioreactor | 1.28 g/L | / | / | [61] |
 | Candida galli PG06 | Bioreactor | 1.12 g/L | 25.7% (molar yield) | / | [20] |
 | Trichosporon asahii MP24 | Bioreactor | 2.40 g/L | 52.5% (molar yield) | / | [21] |
 | Bacillus fusiformis CGMCCl347 | Bioreactor | 3.25 g/L | / | / | [44] |
 | Bacillus fusiformis CGMCC1347 with utilization of HD-8 resin | Bioreactor | 8.10 g/L | 0.29 g/g Isoeugenol | / | [62] |
 | Bacillus fusiformis CGMCC1347 with utilization of HD-8resin after 6 times reuse of immobilized cells | Bioreactor | 39.26 g/L | / | / | [63] |
 | E. coli BL21(DE3) with pET-21a-iem | Bioreactor | / | 0.76 g/g Isoeugenol | 115 g/L/d | [46] |
Glucose | S. cerevisiae VAN286 | Bioreactor | 65Â mg/L | / | / | [28] |
 | S. pombe VAN294 | Bioreactor | 45 mg/L | / | / | [28] |
 | E. coli K-12 MG1655 | Bioreactor | 119 mg/L | / | / | [34] |
 | C. glutamicum PV-IYΔ0324 | Flask | 0.31 g/L | / | / | [32] |
 | E. coli BL21(DE3) VT-4 | Bioreactor | 19.3 mg/L | 1.93 mg/g Glucose | / | [37] |